Transcript — Eagle Mountain City Council, 4 November 2026
Produced by speech recognition from the meeting recording, so it mis-hears names and technical terms. It is a searchable aid to the recording, not a record of equal standing to the approved minutes.
Full transcript
Speaker A: All right.
Speaker B: Welcome, everybody. It is 4 o'clock on the money on November 4th, and we'll welcome you to our work session here with City Council in Eagle Mountain. get right started with our first item. It's a discussion on the strategic, uh, performance incentive programs, and this is Abby Ivory. While she's setting up, Abby and I had a discussion and she told me she's so excited for this.
Speaker C: Is Rich back?
Speaker B: Oh, and I was— I thank you for reminding me. Um, we— Rich called in just a little while ago, uh, Council Member Wood, and he is ill today and not able to join us, so we'll excuse him. And remind me, I'll do that again later.
Speaker D: I'm like, I remember I have to drag it or something like that. Okay, while he's getting that up and going, I'll go ahead and start kind of talking a little bit about this here.
Speaker E: Oh, looks like he might have gotten it.
Speaker D: Thank you so much for letting me come this afternoon.
Speaker F: That's not it.
Speaker D: That's not it.
Speaker E: Well, you want the— you want a presentation, right? Oh, sorry, I'm repeating. Okay, hold on.
Speaker D: Yeah, this, and then present.
Speaker G: We're good.
Speaker D: Okay, thank you, thank you, appreciate it. So thank you so much, um, for letting me come out here. Um, I am proposing— and this is just really just to talk about this and what are the possibilities— a strategic industry performance incentive program. Um, the reason why we are doing this is because we're looking at diversifying our local industries here in Eagle Mountain, and most of the when we have companies that are looking at us, they're looking for certain things that we just don't have, such as rail, freeway access, airport proximity, and then existing buildings as well. The other thing that they look at is workforce, which we do have. So we're trying to find ways to really incentivize companies to come here and invest in Eagle Mountain. We're really looking at doing things like as a targeted industry, so only certain types of businesses can do this. And that we're hoping that by creating a preliminary incentive policy, that it makes it transparent for our city staff, the companies looking to locate here, city council, and residents on what's a possibility. Our goals for this is really to create local jobs, build a stronger economy resilient to industry layoffs like we've seen at Tyson, and create public value. These are things that the public gets out of having these companies come in. Our targeted industries are advanced manufacturing, energy development, life sciences, aerospace and defense. And as a general rule, we would exclude retail and data centers from any kind of incentives this way. Some of the— just a synopsis of the report that I uploaded was that we have at least 100 full-time jobs in Eagle Mountain. The average wage would be at least 100% of the county average right now. It's just over $60,000. They would have at least $50 million in capital expenditure, and the project must fall into that targeted industry. And then this just goes over like the points. So what we do is just preliminary score these as they come in. So if a project came in and talked about what they would like to do, we would preliminary score them on jobs creation, wage level, capital investment, the targeted industry fit, and then they can get some little bonus points, as I like to call them, for working with a sustainability and community compatibility, infrastructure and public benefit, and then also for workforce development. And then at the bottom there, it says the score determines the proposed tier. It does not guarantee an incentive or the tier maximum. So this is just a general guideline.
Speaker G: Abby, what's the difference in your mind between workforce development and jobs created?
Speaker D: So jobs created is just like how many jobs they're bringing in. So a lot of times we'll get something that says, hey, we're gonna We want to do $1.5 billion CapEx with 2,500 jobs in this type of industry. Workforce development is more working with the local high school, with the colleges to create internships and some work-trade programs, things like that. Are they creating, going above and beyond what they normally have to do?
Speaker A: Okay.
Speaker D: You could come in and just start a business here, or you could come in and be a part of the community. That's what we're trying to encourage with this. And then these are just kind of like basic scoring thresholds with the jobs creation, the wage level, capital investment, and then the industry fit. And again, you can get like those little bonus points. And then just kind of based upon that with the scores that we have, what is the maximum tax increment and the maximum amount of years that they would qualify for? And we're kind of basing this off of what's being done like at the state level. The state offers up to a 30%. Some of these other state quasi-agencies such as MIDA or Utah Inland Port also do something like this and kind of show it out there. It doesn't mean you're guaranteed for that, it just gives you an idea of theoretically what you could qualify for.
Speaker B: Did you just— sorry, I'm going to let you jump in here, but did you want us to kind of work through this as you go, or are you going to go through it all?
Speaker D: Whatever you want to do. If you want me to just present it, and— or do you want to go slide by slide, or even I mean, I've read it, so.
Speaker B: Okay, so I wonder if we can kind of go slide by slide then and make sure where the questions are. You want me to go back?
Speaker H: Sure thing.
Speaker B: Because they've all seen it and read it, so like—
Speaker I: Okay.
Speaker B: On that particular one, well, yeah, let's just start here, but go ahead, Ben.
Speaker C: Okay. You just touched on the word increment, and I just maybe, I know what the council understands what increment is, and we understand what increment is, But for the sake of the public and those who may be watching, increment is because right now the tax might be a very minimal amount on agricultural ground. And were it not for this business coming in, this is all we would collect forever. But because they're coming in and investing a lot of money into our community, they're bringing a lot of tax base in, and it's giving a portion of that back to them to help incentivize them to come into this community. We're not coming up with any money up front in the community.
Speaker B: Correct, yeah.
Speaker C: We're not taking any of our existing resources. This is giving some of that back to incentivize them to come in the first place, maybe as an incubator, the first one in line, or all that type of thing. But that's what increment is, and a lot of people don't understand what increment is.
Speaker D: So yes, it's—
Speaker C: It would come anyway.
Speaker D: It's a post— what I'm proposing is a post-performance reimbursement of their property taxes.
Speaker H: Post-performance.
Speaker D: A portion of it, yeah. So they basically have to show that they did create the jobs at the wages that we've agreed to, and that they've spent the money they say they've agreed to spend. So we wouldn't reimburse anything until that is shown.
Speaker C: Right, but I think there's a perception, especially in the community, that we're giving something away and therefore now we have to raise taxes.
Speaker D: This money would have never been here had they not come in in the first place. Correct. But because we're a new city, we only have, you know, only 30 years, we have a lot of greenfield. A lot of the companies really want some existing buildings, so they have to invest in a building and infrastructure and everything to get that going because we don't have the money to front it. So if somebody comes in and says, I want to build a data center or aerospace, something like that, a manufacturing plant, they have to spend the tens or hundreds of millions of dollars to get that built and set up. And then if we do something like this, they're more incentivized to come because they're spending so much money up front. They're willing to come here. Pretty much like the talent of our local residents and workforce is like our biggest asset that we have, but it's not enough to compete nationally for a lot of things. So it's something like this to to get an industry started. For instance, data centers, we did that with the first one, Meta. We're not doing that with any more data centers. We don't need to. We already have them coming without having to incentivize anything. But the problem is, is like data centers don't bring tons of high-paying jobs. And we have a lot of people that are working in the tech industry, which with the layoffs that have been happening lately between Microsoft, Google, it just seems like maybe that could be something that affects our residents. And so we're trying to hedge our bets here and saying, Okay, what are some of these jobs or industries we can bring into Eagle Mountain that allow people to live and work here so they don't have to travel the roads every day? And then also we'll give them the same amount of money that they're making now outside of the city. And that'll bring more, you know, get people off the roads. That'll help with that. That'll also help us have more people spending locally as far as like sales tax dollars coming in. And then resident happiness. They can live and work here. They can get up in the mountains.
Speaker J: Go skiing.
Speaker D: go mountain biking earlier in the day. So this is really trying to recruit all those people. This is just a temporary program though. Once we establish an industry, just like we did with the data centers, we can cut this off and stop it.
Speaker C: Right, because were it not for the first investment into Meta, we wouldn't have the trail of data centers that have come behind that. So it's—
Speaker D: Yeah, they brought in the infrastructure, the 345-kilovolt transmission lines, which then allowed the other data centers and Tyson plant to come in.
Speaker C: Correct.
Speaker D: And now, even though— even if it's not a data center, they still look at our transmission lines and say, okay, what do you have available? How do we tie into that? So because of that investment that Meta made with us and our agreements to reimburse them for some of their property taxes for a portion of time, it's now being able to bring some other things in. We now have the infrastructure to expand on our industries, and so now we're trying to do work with the recruitment of that.
Speaker F: Uh, one, one, uh, comment. Now this is going through the document, which is not up on the slides, but I was just thinking about maybe adding semiconductor manufacturing, that there's a lot of growth in that space. And I don't know that it's as water-heavy, which is, is a concern for residents, but But that can bring a lot of good jobs, like Texas Instruments, Micron. They're coming to Utah, and I feel like we should be competing for some of those projects as they come through.
Speaker D: Yes, that would be included under advanced manufacturing, and so we're actually trying to go after that if they show that they're using low water use. I know that was an interest of yours, is kind of letting y'all know about everything that's coming in as far as water use and that kind of thing. But it's not just how much water they'll be consuming, but it's also what they're putting back into our system. So I work routinely with Brad and saying, okay, this is what the intake and outtake would be on our sewer system, and will that work with what we have? So we're always kind of evaluating things, but this would be something a little bit different from that. But yes, I agree, semiconductor use would be really great too, and anything that has to do with all of our other industries already going on here.
Speaker K: So one of the— I've got a few questions on this, but One question is this: why do we need a framework to begin with? Because it seems to me when we have a framework, we're basically putting our cards out and showing all of our cards to potential applicants, whereas if we don't have a framework, we keep the cards close to our vest, and then when these potential employers come to us, they don't know what our gives are. They have to talk to us. It seems like we have a better negotiating hand if we just keep this close to our vest.
Speaker J: Thank you.
Speaker K: giving you some idea that, yeah, depending on these circumstances, you might be able to let them know, hey, there might be a potential here, I need to talk to the counsel, without giving anything away. It seems here that we're just putting all our cards out and then we lose some of the negotiating power.
Speaker D: So I totally understand where you're coming from because I, you know, own a mortgage company. You come from the real estate world, and so you're trying to get the most you possibly can for the lowest amount of price. The difference is, is people are approaching you and saying, I want to buy that house or buy that business, What price can I get it at? That's one way of looking at it, but what really actually happens in the site selector world is they are viewing us way before they even come and call us. So they're looking at our sound ordinance. That's why we upped our decibels for industrial areas. They're looking at our zoning. If it shows an agriculture zone, they don't even bother with rezoning requests. They just eliminate us.
Speaker L: Thank you.
Speaker D: So, and then they look at incentives.
Speaker B: So I think the, the really question that we're trying to decide here as a body is, yeah, as Abby's done a really good job and there's site selectors out there that are, that she's dealing with, and we don't— they might work for multiple different companies and things like that, but if the zone's not already in place and there's not some kind of framework that she can work within, they're like, yeah, we're not looking in your area. So it's more of a Not— I don't think any of us want to show our cards. What we want to do is empower Abby to say, hey, if they say, is this something you guys would do, she can say, well, we can always ask. It's never, yeah, let's do that. It's, yeah, that's within our framework.
Speaker E: But isn't, Mayor, isn't the RTI overlay zone already the mechanism that we're using to kind of create a runway? I think that's—
Speaker D: it is, but it's not in place on a lot of those areas. So you still have to request a zone change. When I am going to these conferences, I've been going like once a month, I'm going to a lot of like private dinners with specific site selectors, and I'm asking them these questions. And I specifically wondered about the ag and RTI overlay zone. I said, if it's already— if it's zoned agriculture, you know that that's just a placeholder, right? And he said, no, I don't, and I'm not going to ask. I'm just going to move on to the next place. They're just not even going to do that.
Speaker E: I'm going to just share some thoughts. I'm going to wrestle with this, Abby, and not because it doesn't make some sense, but because I tend to agree with what Councilmember Whiting says. I don't think we should be projecting our limits of where we're willing to go with some incentives. Frankly, I don't think we should be giving a lot of incentives to business that's coming in. For me, they need to convince us that it's a worthwhile endeavor and that they're going to bring something of value. say, well, if it's 100 employees, and see them shut down a plant in Delta and bring 50 employees from Delta so they can meet that 100 threshold and qualify for an incentive. For me, that just doesn't make a lot of sense. It has to do something to answer that but-for question that Ben talked about.
Speaker J: Mm-hmm.
Speaker E: That if they don't come, then there isn't going to be any economic activity. But I frankly think that we are mature enough and growing beyond where we need to beg people to come and be a part of our community. I think we have demonstrated that we are a community that can, that can respond to the needs of big industry, to the residential developers. Um, and I'm just unwilling to telegraph that on the front end. So I, I want to be very candid with you about that.
Speaker D: I appreciate that.
Speaker E: Um, and so I'm, I'm listening and I'm thinking, so how do we do that without telegraphing it? And the RTI Oberlin overlay makes sense to me, and perhaps that's what we should do, is identify some areas in the city where we want to encourage that type of development. And maybe we create an RTI Overlay Zone 2. But I don't want it to do— I don't want it to address incentives in any way. That just maybe mimics the requirements of an RTI Overlay 1, but it limits the types of uses that can come. That's where my mind would go, and that for me might be a little more targeted way to say we want these types of businesses in this area of the city, and we've already done the work to create a landing spot for you and an administrative process that has to follow some of the guidelines that are already in there. I'm just going to leave that out there for some thoughts.
Speaker B: So I'll say that I completely agree with you, which is why I was trying to kind of steer that conversation in that direction to say for her to do her job, then can we put some guardrails so she's not wasting her time with people that unless it's X, they wouldn't even come? So like, go to the next slide. For me, one thing that I would probably wrestle with that you would say is I'm never going 25 years. Anything— I mean, we already have master development agreements that, that we want to end at 6 years specifically. So is there a reason we'd ever go above 25 years? There was a time we went 40. But I think that for me, I can tell Abby, no matter the business, 20 years is my appetite. Now, if somebody says we've got to have 40 years, she can just say, well, go somewhere else. So I'm trying to say I agree with you, but give her an idea of, as she's at these conferences, say that's a heck no. Anything under that, we can ask.
Speaker E: And Mayor, I think there's tremendous value in what she just stated to us. I mean, she said, look, these are the things that I'm wrestling with when I'm out there trying to make contact and to put Eagle Mountain front and center in front of these site selectors, right? Zoning is a problem. If it's not zoned correctly, they won't even talk to you. I think that's something we can address. So what other challenges are you finding? Because what I'm unwilling to do is to say, here's a template to come and get the maximum incentives from Eagle Mountain's residents. No, I'm not going to do that.
Speaker D: A lot of it is just that. having access to rail. I did meet with some rail developers about, you know, would our valley be a good place to have maybe a transload facility or something like that? And so we really looked at what the possibilities would be, and it just doesn't work. We're just too close to Tooele and the Savage rail yard. So we, you know, we don't have the proximity to a lot of things that they really want. But so it's just a matter of like trying to entice people to come here.
Speaker A: But—
Speaker E: So for me, and this is a perfect segue into something that has just been hanging, and I know that there's reasons for it, but this is something we should be addressing in the general plan. Mhm.
Speaker G: When you— can you elaborate a little bit more on what you mean by that and how we'd address it in the general plan? Because I had something that I jotted down and I want to see if it's on the same—
Speaker E: Look, in the, in the general plan, you can identify those areas that you're targeting for that, and we can then bring those areas forward and, and rezone them so that We're saying this is a runway and a pathway to land this type of development in these areas. And I think that you have to do that from an overall concept of what does the city look like at build out and which areas are we gonna target first? And I think you have to target the first area you wanna see that happen.
Speaker G: Hmm.
Speaker E: And perhaps you identify some other areas that are future potential RTI 2. I don't know what you call it. Look, we're spitballing. I'm spitballing.
Speaker D: I love it. No, it's great. That's what the whole purpose of this is, is just to talk about what the possibilities are and what you want to see and what you don't want to see.
Speaker G: I actually— so while everyone else was kind of sharing their thoughts, I jotted down future land use designation question mark, because one of the things we've been told by different developers, especially when it comes to commercial business park, those types of things, they'll come in and say 140 acres is way too much for this particular land use designation. And it's not that we expect the full 140 acres to go into that, it's just that's the approximate area in the city that we think that this makes sense, and that's based off of the feedback we're getting from residents. So I do think that I hear what you're saying about RTI and zoning, and maybe we need to lean a little bit more into either a secondary zone for RTI or really push and clarify within our general plan with our future land use designation. Um, do you have any follow-up to that? Because I've got another—
Speaker E: No, I'm just, I'm thinking about the RTI as it exists currently. I mean, we could certainly just get into the RTI and modify the, the approved uses, right? I mean, you could do that as well, as long as you're okay with the existing zoning having those uses come in in proximity to what's already going on in those areas. So go ahead.
Speaker G: Um, one of the things that I was thinking about when I first started on City Council, it was pre-META, and I was just a teeny tiny little baby City Council member when that got approved. But the work leading up to META had been taking place for years before I got onto City Council. There was extensive research because we really do have a lot of hurdles as a city when it comes to attracting business to us. And they looked at what we could do and they said data centers, because they'll use some of the water that we have to use up, otherwise it's going to cost us a fortune. And they're okay with being at the end of the line where there's not a lot of through traffic. And that worked out great. The, the city said, we're going to go for this, very specific. put the incentives there, and we're starting to reap the benefits from that because we have data centers coming now without any incentive. But I— the question that I asked after we got Meta, and I think after Google was approved, was what is our next data center? And there's air quotes around that. So, and I don't think we've ever determined what that is. And maybe it is advanced air mobility, maybe it is semiconductor manufacturing. But I think before we do anything like this or go too crazy, we need to study out what that next data center type thing is going to be for us in our city. And I don't think we've figured that out yet.
Speaker F: Who are you having dinner with when you go to these conferences? When you say industrial, In my head, I think of driving to the airport through West Valley, and it's just acres and acres and acres of buildings and warehouses and things like that.
Speaker D: And I'm like, I don't care about that. Yeah, you don't want that look. I agree with you. You know, I definitely, when I came on board here, I was told in no uncertain terms by our lovely recorder, like, you better keep my lights dim, right? I like my dark skies. And then the environment was really important, wildlife preservation. And, you know, being here for a year now, I've really gotten a sense of the community and how they want things. They want the traffic off the roads. They want some of these assets like rec buildings and more places to play and have fun together as a family. I really think that increasing our jobs here because of advanced manufacturing and aerospace or something like that, but make sure you put it out of the way so it doesn't impact their life. When I do go to these conferences, it's mostly site selectors and they represent many many different companies, everything from foreign, domestic investments. Like, I just met with the Korean delegation last week. And then we have other ones that are doing, like, food manufacturing. And because it really can impact our sewer, I'm, like, not too keen on that. We're like, I'm not really into that. So, but, you know, I really think about what are the wages on that type of facility. You know, we can't have all high wages. We kind of need to have the high, the middle, and the lower. That way we can have a balanced economy here, or you'll deal with a situation that Park City has where there's so much money that comes in that people can't afford to live and work there. We don't want that. So we're trying to really get things diversified. And then looking at the talent of our residents already, most of them work in tech. How does that translate into other jobs? Nobody's going to stop working in Lehigh, Silicon Slopes, where they can make, you know, 6 figures plus a year to come work at, you know, a meat processing facility here. It's not going to happen. So we need to do something that will entice them to do better. So a lot of those, you know, computer tech and computer engineering jobs translate really well over to aerospace innovation. And so that's what we're looking to do, is trying to bring that in, because that way people can live, stay here, less people on our roads. And I'm sure a lot of the residents would appreciate that.
Speaker G: One more thing. Thank you, Mayor, for letting me. I like that forward with a conversation about this, because I think we— this is a nudge for us to have a discussion about what to do with this. But one thing that I keep going back to, and I had this conversation earlier today with Councilmember Wright, um, we're putting together or proposing to put together something like this for the really big fish, but I see every day the smaller fish that are trying to make things work, and smaller fish who start in their basements or their garages and then move to a location here in Eagle Mountain and then end up having to move to a neighboring city because there's nothing else for them to move up to when they outgrow their location here in Eagle Mountain. And I think we need a mix. I think we need a mix of small and a mix of big to make everything work. But I also am finding myself asking, what are we doing for those smaller businesses, or even the land developers that help facilitate creating spaces for some of those smaller businesses? We, um, we talked earlier about incentives and how they're a reimbursement of an investment in what they're putting into our city. But I look around at some of our small and mid-sized businesses in our community and They're the first ones to sign up to sponsor the soccer jerseys or to sponsor the Turkey Trot or to help with the Wildlife Alliance or whatever. And, and I think that we would be doing a disservice to our overall business ecosystem if we didn't stop and think about what we could be doing as a city to make it more hospitable for those size businesses too.
Speaker D: A lot of these communities that have a lot of CRAs under the RDAs, they use the admin fee to create like a revolving loan fund that can be used to help support smaller businesses. So that is an option to do, and it's allowed by state statute to do something like that. So, and really a lot of this is, is, you know, it's, it's hard to kind of create a company that supports data centers, but could that happen in aerospace or manufacturing where you have the big ones come in and then all these little things come in? If you look at what happened, um, 5 years ago, I had to give a report on like what businesses have come in the last 5 years. So I just went like Google, You know, satellite back 5 years, and all of the Macy's Corner didn't even exist. The Maverick, all those little places and stuff like that. I agree. I used to be a chamber director as well, so I agree. I'm all for small businesses and making them thrive. I love to eat at like little mom-and-pop shops, and so I think that's really important as well. And I'd love to collaborate on some things to get that going as well.
Speaker E: So, Abby, you're— I mean, your excitement's infectious. I'm grateful that you're on the team. And I don't want to rein that in.
Speaker M: I know.
Speaker E: So I don't want to— I am not trying to put a cloud on anything, okay? I want to be clear about that. But what I'm hearing in this discussion is that there are some holes in our portfolio that we are unable to put forward to the business community as whole. And I like what Councilmember Clark said. You know, maybe we need to take a look at if we're going to target those types of industries, let's pick one and let's say let's go find that and let's bring them in. And then we can talk incentives if we see that that's going to have some value. I also think zoning is one of the issues I heard you say is a problem and business space. There's not existing space.
Speaker N: Correct.
Speaker E: So maybe those are 2 things that we could start to tackle to create a landing spot for some of these where you can say, do you know what we just did? We just rezoned a bunch of property that isn't— that, that with this type of entitlement, and it allows you this runway to come in and to start to move your business forward. Or we've been working on developing some commercial space and we're just looking for the right partner, and to the right partner we might be able to do X, Y, or Z. That— I just, I think that would be—
Speaker D: It makes sense with what you're saying, and, and it's one of the things I've been doing, like these and I talk about the need for flex space, office space, and then smaller industrial park, and how can we bring them in. And the problem really lies in they're taking all the risk with building the building and then not having somebody in it already. You could have a large warehouse that could be sitting there for 1 or 2 years, and they're paying interest on that. And if we're not doing anything to help that along, it's really hurting them. Thank you. It's just too big of a risk for them. So that's why we see so many times, and just for residents out there, a lot of times these little retail squares and stuff like that, they already have businesses that are going in there and they wouldn't have started them unless they were fully built out.
Speaker E: But if that's a consistent problem, I think that we can look at that. And that's where you might change my mind about an incentive. If we can get someone that's willing to come in and take the risk, we can say, look, we'll take the risk with you for a period of time because the building is going to be there and that property is going to be there. And if we need to return a portion of that to take that risk to start to develop the business community and to provide some of those things that are missing in our portfolio, I think that's how we could do it effectively.
Speaker D: And I think having— going to these conferences and meeting with site selectors and talking with them one-on-one and saying, yes, we've done incentives in the past, we can definitely look at something in the future, is helping. Some of the times we just get them via email and then have to respond to them.
Speaker B: via email.
Speaker D: I have no way to show my nice shiny face here, you know, happy face, and entice them in that way. So that's the hardest part, is really getting them in without talking to them. So I might just have to step up my game when it comes to these conferences and really get in with them.
Speaker E: But just do it, just do a video, just do a little blurb with you in it.
Speaker D: Here's a little invitation from me.
Speaker E: Send that out with the email. They'll be like, who is this woman? I've got to get to know her in Eagle Mountain City.
Speaker F: Yeah, I think for the site selectors it would be good to know, because they're screening us out, like you said, well before.
Speaker D: They really do.
Speaker F: That's what we need to focus on, is what's going to catch us in their screen where we become a candidate before they ever meet with us or see you. That if it's seeing an RTI overlay zone, okay, railroad— I don't really know that we want railroad, but maybe we do.
Speaker D: Don't worry, we're, we're not.
Speaker F: But look, you know, we're not heading down that path. But if there's 3 or 4 things that would help us screen better, I think we should focus on those areas so we screen.
Speaker B: I think that's what we really need you to bring back, Abby, or something. Is— so zoning's one. Like, what are the other things that we're getting, uh, right, eliminated?
Speaker D: I— yeah, some of it was, you know, like overhauling our website, the economic development, so they can just go on and see exactly where the sites are. They just— they're like teenagers nowadays. They don't want to talk to anybody in the real world. They just want to go on and look at the information. And so we're going to work on that as well. I'll be in Grand Rapids next week at another site selector conference, and I'll try and curtail some more of those people and find out, like, how can I improve it. I've been really grateful because they have done so many evaluations of what we're offering and how we can improve it to what they are wanting.
Speaker C: So can I— go ahead, sorry. I was just going to recap. the discussion a little bit. What I, I believe the direction— what I'm hearing is that the council doesn't want to show your cards. You want to be more intentional about the direction that you're going, and you can do that by, uh, going through the general plan and getting that completed, and also working on zoning that is maybe more targeted zoning so that you can effectuate the end that you want to try to create and give Abby the tools that she needs. You want her to keep the excitement that she has. You don't— you're not trying to stifle that whatsoever. But at the same time, I'm sure that Abby doesn't want to get ahead of her skis. I think we've used that term a couple of times.
Speaker H: Right.
Speaker C: That she wants to make sure that she's working within the framework that you guys would have. And even if it may not be something on our website, it's something that you can informally work with her so that she has good guidance when meeting with others. And in general, Abby has the opportunity to reach out to you at any time to get your feedback. and direction on specific issues, specific cases, and you've always been very responsive into that. And ultimately, we want to have a very strategic, very contemplative, very intentional plan to move forward.
Speaker E: Yes.
Speaker K: Can I ask just 2 quick questions about that?
Speaker F: Sure.
Speaker K: In terms of checking boxes, can we just not have a— like on our economic development portion of our website, can't we have something that says, hey, incentives may be available, Here's sort of the criteria we're looking at. Contact us for details.
Speaker D: Yes, that's what I put out now. Yeah, that is what I'm doing now. I had hoped that maybe this would be more, you know, I'm hearing from residents that they want more transparency in what we're doing, and I thought maybe if we had a framework so they could understand what was happening, why we're giving it, and what the limits are, that would then help them understand my job and your job and why we're doing business recruitment and what kind of things we're doing for it.
Speaker C: You know, ultimately, you see this kind of a framework in a very mature city that's got a lot of industry and it's grown and it's— we're kind of that gangly teenager. We're no longer in the phase of—
Speaker E: Speak for yourself.
Speaker C: Well, we're no longer in the phase of saying we want it all, all the above, we'll take anything. But we're not at that point where we want to exclude anything. with rigid frameworks that maybe don't work for us. We want to be intentional and we're still trying to figure out our arms and our legs and how to move forward. It's going to take a strong dialogue between the body and the department.
Speaker D: I think it's a perfect game plan.
Speaker E: Thank you.
Speaker F: This last question.
Speaker K: You say they're looking at zoning excluding us. Do they not look at the future land use map?
Speaker D: No, not really unless they have a site selected. They're really going— if you think about it, how many communities across the country They're looking— they're not just looking in Utah, they're looking all over the U.S. and what can happen. You know, I've made friendships with the part— with our partners in the state and other agencies that are kind of feeding some of these to us. I've noticed they're not coming out in RFIs. They're actually being, you know, because I'm talking so much about what I'm doing, I'm putting it out there on social media. I'm like ad nauseam getting out what we're doing and how great we are, and that's helping some. But in reality A lot of it is just coming— some of the information will exclude stuff. And for some of these, if it hadn't been for like a personal invitation to lunch or dinner or something like that, they would have never even looked at us.
Speaker B: So is there any other questions or slides that we haven't seen or any other direction? I know we kind of cut you off in the middle. Is there anything else that you'd like to have specific questions on?
Speaker D: No, I just wanted feedback on this, and I think I've gotten everything unless Councilmember Wood is online and He wants to add anything?
Speaker B: He's not online to my knowledge. He said he couldn't make it.
Speaker M: That's okay.
Speaker B: I talked to him a little bit, but go ahead.
Speaker F: Well, I was just going to ask, because you, you brought up the reason for this is more transparency with residents, which I agree with. I, I talked to, um, Evan. I think he's working on some things for the website to break down, because there's a lot of confusion around Meta and why did we bring them on and what are the, what are the, uh, tax tax incentives, having that out with these projects as they come through would be great, just to have that available. Whatever can be publicly made available would go a long way with residents there. But I think Evan's already— and maybe you're working on that project as well.
Speaker D: Yeah, no, he worked on that, and that's great. It was just— I think it was more for data centers and what happened there with the incentives. We were looking just to do a framework for our targeted industries and how that could play out, because really my focus has been if we can get high-paying jobs in companies, manufacturing companies or whatever here, if we can get high-paying jobs, then the retail will follow. Everybody wants an Olive Garden or a Texas Roadhouse or something, but we have too many people that leave during the day. So how do we create the environment for jobs here locally that people stay here and spend here locally that will entice these other retail projects to come in?
Speaker B: We definitely know there would be nothing to the west of us. all 20-something acres of that if it wasn't for some of the stuff that we brought in.
Speaker C: I bet Lehigh once said that about west of them.
Speaker B: Well, the point of the mountain. That was a dairy farm when I was a kid and there was nothing there. So yeah, west meaning us.
Speaker E: Mayor, I mean, I really liked what Councilmember Hewish said because I think that, I think if we, and I don't want to create a, I'm not looking for an advertisement, let me say it that way, but I think that just some factual data that the residents could listen to and understand— I mean, the water, Melissa mentioned it in her comments, right? I mean, I don't think most people recognize that that first data center came in and really saved the residents from a tremendous tax increase that they were going to be looking at because there was water that had to be taken down from our contract from CUP. It had to happen. And so either the residents were going to pay for it or an industry business was going to come in and help pay for it. And Meta, in fact, did that. I don't think people realize that. And so the circumstances on the ground in 2017 or 2018 or whenever that happened were much different than they are today, just as our circumstance is different. And the residents are going to question everything we've done. In fact, they're already doing it and they'll continue to do it. And that's okay, they should. But I think context is what really matters. And I think, Evan, if you're working on that, I really would like to encourage that the complete story is out there where people can evaluate it and look at it. I don't want it to be propaganda, that's not my goal. But I would like to have the factual data so that they understand that we had an obligation on a contract to put some water to use, and we were going to pay for it whether we put it to use or not. Anyway, and electricity, they brought in that 3, that 345, 350.
Speaker D: That's really helped out a lot. A lot of times even manufacturing plants can't do anything without that. They need like a 3-phase.
Speaker E: I just don't think our residents really understand that. I didn't understand it until I landed here, and even being here, I still know there's things I don't know. But the more I learn, the more I go, oh well, that makes sense. Somebody made a decision that I've questioned and I've wondered about, but had I sat there at that time, I might have found yourself in exactly the same spot with all of the context.
Speaker D: Just to give a little plug to Natalie, she does the resident engagement, the School of Correct. So, and it, it is something that I go over in that. So if anybody's interested in why we do things, I do explain it. And sometimes I give a little, maybe a little sneak peek at some things coming up in the future. So if you want to be on the in, you should go to that.
Speaker F: And I'll just add one thing. I noticed on the Eagle Mountain Citizens page, you'll jump in When people start bagging on stuff they don't know anything about, I appreciate you throwing yourself out there to say, hey, if you have any questions, call me. It's so helpful that people feel like they have that engagement. You know, we have to be careful to not create a quorum, but you jumping in and helping answer questions.
Speaker D: I appreciate that. I, I don't know if people realize how much effort goes into vetting out a business beforehand. I feel a certain amount of responsibility to the city and the residents, especially because I think if I lived here, what would I want to see? Well, what about like a heat island or something? I research it to the fullest extent. I want to know where it came from, what's the rebuttal argument about it, and then how does that affect us out here? You know, I heard a lot about, you know, air pollutants. We want to preserve that. I work a lot with Miriam with the wildlife preservation, and it's just— it's been a lot going through that. And so I do want to make sure that I help people out. My phone number is on the ballot.
Speaker H: Thank you.
Speaker D: out there, anybody, I always put that in, you know, the Facebook, like, call me, I'm here night or day, the weekend, I don't care. I'm single, I don't have a life. So just call me and we can talk about it. I'll take you out, I'll drive you by the data centers, I'll drive you by wherever you want to go, and we could talk about it and have a discussion. It doesn't need to be argumentative, and it just— we're just going to discuss it. And I wish more people would do that, but I've never received a phone call once when I put that out there.
Speaker G: So.
Speaker H: Sorry.
Speaker B: Okay, I appreciate it. I think we've got good direction.
Speaker H: Yes.
Speaker B: Everybody feels good?
Speaker L: Yeah.
Speaker B: All right, thank you, Abby. We do have a lot of work to do, so we'll move right on to item 1B. This is a water rights code that we've been working on. I know Brandon's got some information. And Brandon, just for your information, I didn't get a chance to talk to you. I do know that we have some of our development partners here that have weighed in, and I'm inclined to have them help us get this Right, so it's kind of both sides. So address some of our issues, what we're trying to tackle, and when it's appropriate, we might get some feedback as well.
Speaker O: Sounds great.
Speaker E: Let me pull this up.
Speaker O: Mainly be working off—
Speaker E: let's see here. I am—
Speaker P: there we go.
Speaker O: I'll mainly be working off of the proposal itself, but just give you a couple of highlights to introduce it.
Speaker E: So if I can get this thing to— Brendan, can you go up front?
Speaker A: The fire guy is asking you to speak up.
Speaker O: I'm basically mumbling here saying I can't get this thing to turn on. And I think this happened last time.
Speaker G: Here comes the stage manager.
Speaker J: The reverse.
Speaker O: The screen is the presentation. Yeah, that's exactly what's happening. Do you know how to flip this?
Speaker E: We'll work it out.
Speaker O: Because this was the problem at Planning Commission last— um, solid. So this, uh, has been in the works for, uh, for a number of months now. I think we started on this clear back in June— well, started drafting it June, July, and we've had discussions well before that. It's a pretty broad-based code. It touches— there's 10 sections to this. It's touching 3 titles. I think it gets into Title 13, Title 17, Title 16, mainly Title 16. It includes a brand new chapter, 1642. And so I couldn't figure it out. Oh, there you go.
Speaker L: You did it.
Speaker O: So we've had this water rights process of dedicating, accepting dedicating water, and there's been a little bit of confusion at times, and so this is This is being put forth to kind of bring some clarity to bring clarity to that process. Through this process, we're trying to identify we we're setting forth or establishing the position that we propose to call a water rights analyst. We we do have a water rights expert here at our city, and and that person in the code would be called our water rights analyst. It's code. Helps to establish when water rights would be dedicated to the city. Water rights, what the proposal is, is that residential water would be dedicated at the time of, if someone's going through the master development plan process, they would dedicate residential water at that time. If they're dedicating, if there's other uses, it would be dedicated at the time of building permit. A couple of other things that we've tried to address in this, and this is kind of part of a bigger process of trying to get in front of development and make sure we have proper infrastructure, roads and so forth. And so we're proposing that our concept plan include a include the submittal of a will-serve letter so that the purpose of that will-serve letter is one, for the city to say, yep, we can, you know, you developer have shown us that you have water. And number 2, there's sufficient infrastructure in the area. So, Again, trying to get in front of that process of making sure that we're connecting our utilities, making sure the utilities are in the area of where development's going, or having a plan for getting utilities to that area.
Speaker E: What's the— may I ask you this question? What's the process if, if there's a determination that's made that you have sufficient water but the infrastructure is not there to support it? What, what, what happens then?
Speaker O: So they need to go through the— they're going to have to submit a utility plan that they're going to go— what I was just referring to is the concept plan. So obviously through the concept plan we're going to say, well, you don't have sufficient utilities, and then they're going to have to come at the master development plan stage and show us a utility plan to bring the utilities to that area. So, um, so we've— you, I'm sure you've, you've read the code and it's pretty lengthy. What I want to do is show, since that code's been written, I've taken this to the Planning Commission for a work session, and they gave us some feedback. We had— I've had subsequent discussions with the mayor and with Marcus, and I wanted to show you, highlight a couple of things, and then maybe just kind of go from there. So, Let me exit this and then go to the—
Speaker E: see if I can open this up for you.
Speaker O: So what I did here, and I'll make this bigger. Anything that has changed— so what I'm basically telling you, there have been a couple of changes that have been made. Sense from the— these are changes that aren't in the copy that you received. So anything in yellow, and I'm going to go through and explain that to you right now, and I think these are all really good changes, and these came from Planning Commission, the mayor, or Marcus. So this section of code right here is addressing water rights for master development plans. We wanted to be a little bit more clear, um, with the language here that— wanted to be clear that res— that residential water has to— or water for residential use has to be dedicated to the city at the time of master development— at the time of the master development plan and agreement application process. It It essentially said that, but when we were looking at the language, it was maybe— could be cleared up a little bit.
Speaker E: And our current process is when does that dedication take place? At C of O? When does it take place?
Speaker O: Yeah, it's currently happening. There's been uncertainty in that. Sometimes I've seen it happening at building permit stage. That's why we're doing this. We're trying to be clear that it's happening at the master development stage. So we made that change. We also— actually, one other thing I didn't mention. I did get feedback from Brad and John. They also gave me an additional comment. I tried to address that. And it was kind of— Brad and John and the Planning Commission on this section. So the idea— this used to be called determination of water requirements, and, and I think it was Brad who's like, hey, we don't want the engineer— and I completely agree with him— we don't want our city engineer determining the quantity of water rights or basically preparing the application for the developer. We want the developer to come in and tell us how much water they think they're gonna need for the use, and then we'll confirm it. We'll say, we'll go and do our own calculations and say, yep, we think that's right, or no, we think you need to add a little bit more water to your proposal. So this language was updated to kinda hit home that point, to get rid of the word identify and use the word confirm, I think is the biggest key there. Other thing that we changed, there's just a couple of things here.
Speaker A: Water. Water.
Speaker O: So for non-residential uses like commercial and industrial, commercial and industrial uses, water comes— would come at the first permit for like a shell or just for the primary building. We want the ability— we're putting in there the ability to require additional water through the building permit process if a future tenant comes in and say they went from like— we've got the game store across the street. If they leave and we have an intensive water use go in there, we want the ability to say, hey, we need a little bit more water for this new restaurant coming in or— Or a salon or whatever.
Speaker E: So—
Speaker C: Can I jump in there real quick?
Speaker F: Yeah, sure.
Speaker C: I think one of the issues that we've run into quite a bit with— is that we've historically been requiring this at the tenant improvement level.
Speaker O: Yeah.
Speaker C: And instead of at the shell level. And what happens is, at the shell level, we're having the building permit, we're designing it, maybe designing for a restaurant. We don't know exactly what type of restaurant or whatever, but we're we don't— we're not requiring enough water at that shell level.
Speaker O: Right.
Speaker C: And then a tenant will come in at the tenant improvement level, and they're moving forward, and maybe it's a local restaurant that just is coming in. They'll come through, they have their plan, they're putting all their improvements in and all this kind of stuff, and all of a sudden, they get hit with something like, oh my goodness, I need to bring in 2 acre-feet of water. That's, you know, $50,000, $80,000, $70,000, whatever. And it totally blows their plan. And then you see them now opening right-of-way and the stalling out and whatnot, when really this should have been addressed at the shell level and then making minor tweaks at the tenant improvement level, not at the shell. You know what I mean?
Speaker A: Yeah.
Speaker C: It should be up front. It shouldn't be on that end business, and suddenly they're carrying a burden and a complete surprise after they've already obtained the loans, got the franchise agreement, started all the tenant improvements, and all of a sudden they get hit with something they completely didn't expect.
Speaker O: That— and that's, that's exactly right. And, and part of the reason that that first section of code that I showed you that we changed, that the next sentence or 2 that I didn't get into that wasn't changed, it actually requires— so at an MDP, an applicant would, through this code, would be required to dedicate residential water to the city. But it also says that they're going— if they have commercial or industrial or whatever other uses, they would have to demonstrate to the city through the MDP process that they have sufficient water so that we don't even get to the point of building permit and wondering if there is water. We're trying to iron those things out and require it at the front of the process so we don't end up with those types of issues.
Speaker A: So, yeah.
Speaker Q: Can I just jump in a little bit and add some more context? So with this, I mean, another thing to kind of go back to I think it was Councilmember Wright that asked the question, but we need to see these early on in the concept plans and whatnot so that we can evaluate them against our master plans. 'Cause we need to know what trunk lines and everything need to go in. And if you have developments coming to come in, that's what we need to measure it against. And we need to know what those projects are because if we're gonna go into a master development plan, With the developer, and they may need to put some of that infrastructure in to provide it, or they need to wait till the utilities get to them. Because before, I think we've ran into scenarios where we've got really far down the road with projects, they're ready to build or they're building and we're closing on them, and then we're trying to figure out how to do projects to facilitate or deliver to them. So this is really an effort to try to clean up that approach and just make sure that we're doing our due diligence so that when somebody comes into the community and they want to land in the community, they can be successful and we can be successful.
Speaker O: This next change—
Speaker C: Yeah, one last thing. Sorry, I had a request for you to pull that microphone nice and close because some of the public can't hear you.
Speaker O: Sorry about that. So this next change here is related to the priority date for water rights that we'll accept. It's pretty straightforward. You can see it right there. If it has a priority date that's prior to 2006, we'll accept that. If it's not, then we've seen concerns. Are aware of issues with the seniority of water rights if they're older than past that date. We we just want to be able to put ourselves in position to to receive water rights that have a better priority date and a better likelihood of not getting I guess as we've we've kind of talked in staff getting a haircut. So all this we're just trying to mature our processes and and put ourselves. In the best position for sustainable development in the future. The rest of these, again, this is kind of a repeat. Some of this language, I— this is Chapter 1660 related to building codes. And so these sections right here just kind of get repeated so that we don't miss them when we're reviewing applications. So that is— those are the changes. You've had the code given to you. It is— and I guess I'll just touch on this for the sake of the audience here. This application touches on kind of these main points. One of the main things in this code Is it? It's saying that any owner of water and land in an application, they have to be the applicant. They have to sign the application. We don't want anybody getting a surprise like, oh my! I didn't didn't know I was this involved with an application, or that we just want full investment into into those applications and no surprises for anybody. Process application or this proposal. It's going to— it will help us to go through and help us to better understand the avail— will help us to understand sooner in the process the availability of water, how much water is going to be required for a certain project. Recently, we've been working with QTS on getting some applications submitted. And we ran into an issue of not knowing how much water would be required for their new buildings. And so we don't want those kinds of issues.
Speaker N: We're trying to—
Speaker O: we want to be able to catch those issues at the forefront of the application process. This application This proposal deals with, sets forth requirements for banking water, for dedication of water rights to the city. It sets forth process for maintaining our records for not only groundwater but CWP water, and again sets forth when water would be dedicated. So that's kind of the highlight of what this code, what's in this code. And I guess I'm here to answer any questions you might have and turn it over to the developers if they have additional feedback.
Speaker A: So.
Speaker E: Brendan, I have a question.
Speaker M: Yeah.
Speaker E: I tried to find the resolution that the council passed restricting the sale of residential water and I was unable to find it. So somebody's going to have to help me find that.
Speaker O: Yeah.
Speaker E: But my recollection is that institutional is not identified in that. as an approved use. And here, this seems to contemplate a change. Right.
Speaker O: Yeah, and that may be— that was, as we discussed it, we discussed— I was under no impression that there was any limitation on— as we discussed it through staff, we didn't feel to limit institutional. And so I guess you may have pointed out that we may need to address it, and that's why we're here to get your feedback.
Speaker E: Well, and I'm not suggesting that we should or shouldn't, but we haven't. And I know that there have been some restrictions placed on at least 2 institutional uses in the city. And then the question that I ask, if we're going to allow that, And that's a, that's a question for the council. But, but my thought process is, is if we're going to allow that, then what defines it as an institutional use? I, I mean, I, I, how do we know that it qualifies in that standard? Because I don't— I'm not aware of any language that does that. Maybe it's in the code somewhere.
Speaker O: We, we don't. I'm not aware of that.
Speaker E: I just, I want to put that on council's radar. I'm, I'm not I'm not saying it should or shouldn't include that, because I have some ambiguous feelings about it.
Speaker O: Right.
Speaker E: But I think if we're going to allow it to move forward and to be an approved use for the contractual water that we have with Central Utah Water Conservancy District, then I think that we should at least define what qualifies as an institutional use.
Speaker O: I think that's a good— thank you.
Speaker F: My question's pretty easy. On the water analyst, I like that, that we're designating somebody for that. Mine was more of a budget question. Do you see this being something that will increase cost from a staffing budget perspective, or will this be added to somebody who's currently already in the budget? Does that make sense?
Speaker O: We have somebody, John Magnus is Okay, I figured.
Speaker F: Just wanted for the residents to know that.
Speaker O: There's no— as far as I know, there's no budget change.
Speaker F: Thanks, John.
Speaker Q: I think maybe just to add to that though, Councilmember Hewish, is that right now we're taking care of it, but as we grow and we mature as a city, as an organization, there may be other staffing and other needs that may need to come online. But that doesn't mean that it's anything that's going to be proposed right at this exact So just want to make that clear.
Speaker E: I'm going to tell you, I love it. I love the code. I think it's really well written. I think it accomplishes the things that I've been concerned about. I mean, I've worked with John a little bit on it, and I love that we're being proactive and that we're planning on the front end to avoid some of those hassles or issues that we've been finding on the tail end, right? If we can't learn from those things, And that's— I think this represents a significant learning curve, and so I'm grateful to staff for working through this.
Speaker C: I think the only thing I wanted to add to all this is that now that we have— or once this gets approved in its final form and we have this process in place, I think it gives us a framework as well to be able to say, okay, this project hasn't met this threshold yet, so it's until they have water or until they're ready to proceed we don't have to take our staff time evaluating everything else and spending meeting after meeting after meeting going down a path that may never materialize if they don't meet this bare minimum requirement.
Speaker B: Can you go where you first started, that first yellow mark? It was number 6.
Speaker A: Yeah.
Speaker B: On 1640, yeah, right there. And just leave that up for a second. I think that's the one that that I've heard, there's been some questions, and maybe I can do my best to preface staff or council anyway, that one of the issues I was brought to my attention on this is, say, a large development, and I can pick any large development that might have thousands of units. We want that to be master planned, and we want for connectivity and trails, and but yet if they had to have all the water, we're talking thousands of acre-feet of water and millions of dollars at the master plan process, yet as it develops out, they might be able to do it on, say, a takedown schedule is what we have on some of them. So to require that all up front is the question. Maybe it needs to be identified, but it can be on more of a takedown or a, you know, just that's what I heard.
Speaker E: And so So I'm gonna ask a water rights question that I don't know the answer to. What is the process for reserving that? If someone owns those rights, and let's say that, I mean, I'm gonna use Firefly as an example. We know that they have a lot of units that are approved, they have a lot of water. And if they were to bring that in and we're like, you have to dedicate 3,000 acre-feet of water to be able to build all these units, or 4,000, or whatever it is. Because those calculations change, we review those and they change. Sometimes they're a little higher, sometimes they're a little lower. I, I think that becomes a bit of a question, but I, I think we plan for the worst and hope for the best, right? So, so my thought process is, how do we— can we reserve those rights to be dedicated to the city and not require that they're dedicated at, at, at the the time that they do it. Maybe it is incremental like the mayor's recommending. And does that give us some sort of right to those rights? That's, that's my concern. My concern is if the developer continues to control them and they haven't dedicated them to the city, are they at risk of going somewhere else?
Speaker B: Somewhere else within the city, possibly. But with that, I, I want to see if, uh, Scott Hazard or, or even Brad, if you guys want to come up, maybe help us explain your questions on this item. Go ahead. Put him on the spot.
Speaker K: Yeah.
Speaker B: And let us know, you know, help us get this right as we're working with developers. Still a discussion. You don't get a vote. Neither do I. But we want to get it right.
Speaker N: I'm well aware, Mayor, that I don't get to vote here.
Speaker B: So—
Speaker N: but I do appreciate you listening. I'm grateful to staff. I'm really supportive of bringing structure to this whole water world within the city. It's something that's really needed. It has been a little all over the map to some extent. And so the overarching intent of bringing structure and predictability and trying to manage some of these expectations is really well received. Mayor, you hit my number one concern, which is what I would classify an extraordinary exaction way too early in the process. I recognize that water is a scarce resource, but you don't require me to bond to prove I have enough money to develop the project that you're entitling day one when you approve my master plan. That happens at final plat. From a developer standpoint, for the private sector, we don't really deploy capital to that extent until we know the market's ready to absorb it. And we know the market's ready to absorb it when we go to final plat. And, you know, take Triumph, for example. I'm a small developer. It's 160 acres. It's 234 units. It's $10 million of water that you would say, give that to me day one, and then it takes me 8, 10 years to absorb that into the market and recover that capital expenditure. I'm really supportive of the idea of saying, hey, demonstrate that you reasonably have water or access to water or a purchase agreement to get water. I have several change applications in process that I'm trying to bring water into the city to— that's incoming, but it's not ready to dedicate. I wouldn't want that timing to hogtie me as a developer on when I could develop and what. Thank you. And the early dedication, I think, brings into question all sorts of other questions. For example, what happens if you change the exaction down the road? Do I get a water right credit back for what I've already dedicated? So on the residential side, I would invite you to reconsider staff's recommendation to dedicate water and maybe just demonstrate that we have a reasonable path to acquire the water, and then allow us to dedicate it as we go. I wouldn't want all of my limited amount of water that I own to be pre-dedicated to a single project, and then I can't do anything else in the city. Even though I have other residential property, I can't develop it because 100% of the water that I had, or most of the water I had, went into one project. And then I can't do something somewhere else because I can't allocate it where the market is absorbing. So those are part of my concerns.
Speaker B: So Scott, just to help us understand then, when's the right time for that? Is it Demonstrate that it's ready at the, at the, uh, master development, or demonstrate that it's available, but then dedicate it plat by plat as a—
Speaker D: Yeah.
Speaker B: Final plat. So that's still prior to building, prior to building permit, but it's plat because, like Triumph as an example, you're gonna have 6 different plats. So each plat you dedicate as it goes.
Speaker N: Dedicate when I— before I record I think that's, that's what we're doing now. The water right is dedicated before the recording of that final plat.
Speaker B: And one of my questions when we get to that is, I know there are concerns at the staff level and for council of will that meet the— we have problems and issues we're trying to solve. Would that address the issue if we did it that way, or do we still create a problem?
Speaker E: I mean, part of my concern— I love that we're having this conversation, Scott, and thank you for your input. It's very helpful. The question that I have is, if you identify that I have these water rights and I want to— so I have the ability to move forward on this project, and then in the next year you bring in another project, you say, I still have these water rights because I haven't used them, and this should allow me to be able to get this moving forward. I think that's at least one of the holes we're going to find on this side of the table.
Speaker N: Yeah.
Speaker E: And how would you address that? What are your thoughts about that?
Speaker N: Really simply, Brett, I acknowledge the concern. I want that flexibility. How's that for straight talk? And I think the private sector should be able to have that flexibility. And if I don't have the water, I can't develop it.
Speaker F: So what did we lose?
Speaker N: We lost maybe some time in the approval and the consideration process, and maybe I've got to mothball a portion of the project of a master plan that I can't deliver until I find the water. But I recognize that concern.
Speaker G: Thank you.
Speaker E: coming in.
Speaker N: It's what I do now. I allocate water and limited resources, or maybe it's just cash and capital or leverage, where I can, where the market is absorbing, and where we can recover the investment. But to lock it all up into a single investment, I'll never want to do a master plan with you. I'll want to break it into small little plaques.
Speaker B: Section it off and not plan.
Speaker N: And just say, here's my little bit that I want to do right now. And then that kind of incentivizes this patchwork quilt development process instead of a very cohesive, well-thought-out master plan. I don't know what the mid to long-term outlet is for solving the water issue.
Speaker E: We're gonna bring in a desalination line from the Pacific Ocean, and we're gonna get California to pay for it. That's what we're gonna do.
Speaker F: You do that.
Speaker N: I don't want to be in the room when we're raising taxes for that.
Speaker E: Neither do we. That's why California is going to pay for it, because they don't seem to mind paying a bunch of taxes.
Speaker N: Yeah, I think overall staff is— oh, sorry, go ahead.
Speaker M: We're having— what he's suggesting is what is currently in the code, and the reason that this code is coming is because what we— the current process is not working.
Speaker B: Well, and that's what I'm trying to figure out is like, how do we get it better with that?
Speaker M: We have about 20,000 vested units, and most of those don't have water that can actually support those units. So we have a significant portion of our city that is sort of in no man's land when it comes to can they develop, can't they develop, is it still vested, is it not vested, where you have somebody coming in, getting entitlements, selling the property based on the increased value due to getting the entitlements, walking away from the project and then with all these promises given to the city and then never being able to deliver on them because they don't have the water to back it up. And what I'm hearing is we want the flexibility to essentially say I'm going to use this water for Project A and B, which is not the intent of the ordinance. The intent of the ordinance is to say I have the water, here are the water rights. Now I think we can have discussions about when's the proper time to dedicate the water, but to say I have this water and I have the same water for this Project B as well, is not— is completely the opposite of what the ordinance is trying to accomplish. It's trying to accomplish saying, I am not going to go— you know, I served my mission in the former Soviet Union, and when it collapsed, there's a whole bunch of buildings that were in partial construction that years later were still in a state of partial construction. And it kind of brings you back to the Sermon on the Mount, talking about where he saying, who would build not knowing whether or not they could complete beforehand, unless they say he started to build and could not finish? And that's what we end up with, is these entitlements where people start a project and they can't finish. That they're, you know, they get the entitlements, they sell it to somebody, and it just sits there and sits there and sits there. And I think that's the evil that we're trying to address, so to speak, is— and I understand the concern is saying, I don't want to dedicate it at preliminary plat or at master development agreement stage because, you know, that's a lot of money that's tied up before I can ever see a return on my investment. I think that's a valid concern. Um, but, um, it doesn't look at what the city's concern is, is that we're entitling these projects— we're essentially, um, and, and I'm not saying that this is Mr. Hazard, but we're essentially incentivizing people to come in to get entitlements and then walk away, make a quick buck and walk away. And that is something that we don't want to encourage.
Speaker B: So my question would be, how do we address the idea that if it's a 10-year absorption, and I'm going to say it's a 15-year absorption, we have projects that are way longer than that, but the master development agreement where we require the water expired in 6 years, they only sold 40% of the product, but we already have their water.
Speaker M: No, I understand it's a legitimate concern, but what the current— what I hear is a critique of what is being proposed, and the solution is to keep the status quo, and we already know the status quo doesn't work.
Speaker B: Well, the status quo won't work. It's just when can— and that's what the discussion is. When is the right time, and how does that—
Speaker N: So I think that this current proposal really helps bring structure to the current way that we're doing it. I've had some conversation with staff. I, you know, poor Brandon, Brad, I'm like, how are we doing this? Like, we're figuring this out, we're working together and just trying to figure out how to, how to prove that we have water. Um, you know, this had structures to that to demonstrate, you know, how will we demonstrate that we have water, that water can be used for development, etc. Um, you know, Marcus, I, you know, you're the expert in the room on, you know, what are the risks that the city undertakes when you convey vested rights to a developer, and how does that relate to whether or not water rights were dedicated? I think that's probably the crux of the issue that needs to be considered here. But whether I dedicate the water to you, or I show you that I have water or access to water, you're still encumbering it, and I still have to buy it, or I still have to own it. I'm still deploying the capital, because otherwise I can't show you that I have the water, unless somebody gave me a 5 or 10-year takedown period, And any water rights that I know of in this valley that are available for sale are available for sale for about 3 minutes. And then they're gobbled up, somebody pays cash, and they're gone. So, whether I just show you I have water and say it's all for this project, but I'm not going to dedicate it now, it's still encumbered because I can't allocate it anywhere else. So, is there a better way to mitigate the risk without saddling this extraordinary capital exaction on the private sector. But that's my question.
Speaker M: I mean, I don't think we're gonna solve this right now. I think we've already spent twice as long as, or 3 times as long as we allocated for this in the approximate time. So I mean, I do think that it makes sense for us to try to work through this outside of a City Council meeting.
Speaker E: Thank you.
Speaker B: That's what I was— that's where I wanted to try to see if there was some ground to move.
Speaker C: So do you—
Speaker K: did you have—
Speaker B: I know you had some comments, or—
Speaker F: It was just more of a question of hypothecation. Like, we see this with banking. We've got a deposit over here, but I'm gonna lend out 9 more dollars somewhere else. Is that the issue that, Marcus, that you're bringing up, that developers are saying, we've got water, and then we're rehypothecating those same water rights on another project?
Speaker M: I mean, there's no way to stop that. Especially if that other project's outside the city. So, I mean, most developers are developing in more than one city.
Speaker F: So there's no way to track that or watch it or—
Speaker M: Unless the person's exclusively developing in Eagle Mountain City, no.
Speaker F: Okay.
Speaker B: But most of— but those waters can't be transferred out of zones, and most of our zone is all one zone anyway, right? 52?
Speaker N: 54.
Speaker C: 54.
Speaker B: So even, I mean, you can't take 54 water to Lehi. Or South Jordan.
Speaker M: I don't know the precise boundaries of 54.
Speaker N: West of the Jordan River, a lot could go to Saratoga, Cedar Fort, Fairfield, anywhere in the Cedar Valley.
Speaker C: Is that an issue, Scott?
Speaker F: Yeah, I mean, west of the Jordan River and Lehi, so. Is that something that happens in the developer community where shared water rights are being rehypothecated for other projects back and forth? Like, hey, I've got water over here, but then they turn around and use those same I mean, I've seen that happen.
Speaker N: I mean, not hypothecated as far as pledged to a city, but leveraged and borrowed upon. But that's why the city requires title insurance when we dedicate water to the city to make sure it's clear.
Speaker F: But pre-dedication, that can happen?
Speaker N: I've never done it. I'm sure it probably happens.
Speaker F: All right.
Speaker C: Thanks.
Speaker B: So I think there's 90% of this is pretty good. We say that, and then Brandon or John can clean up what best we can. Is that— do you think there's room? You can come up so we can hear you. Um, thanks, Scott. But so there's room for a little bit of movement on this, or—
Speaker E: Yeah, I think we can find some movement. Instead of getting a dedication, we might require them to bank the water, and banking would move it into one of our city-owned wells. And from that point forward, they would still own the water, But the water could not be taken away from the city. They would have to either sell it to another developer to get their money back or use it for a different project. But at least the water would be in the system and be held onto. Do they have to pay for the full amount of the water to bank it? If they own the water, they would just do a change application, change of point of diversion. It would still be in their name. They would still have the rights to it. But it could not be pulled out of the city's well, 'cause it would go to municipal use. So they would have to sell it to another developer. They would still hold the deeds. I think we can find a way around to make it work.
Speaker B: But the number one issue, it has happened.
Speaker E: There was a developer who dedicated the same water rights twice, was not caught. 40 acre-feet we're on the hook for. That is why we're trying to make sure it does not happen again.
Speaker M: Thank you.
Speaker B: Is there any other comments on this or directions? So you feel good?
Speaker O: Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker B: Okay.
Speaker Q: I was just going to say, just to be clear, like when— like Scott mentioned, at final plat on a residential, I mean, that's when we would require it, and it's when they go record. And a lot of times they have already put all the infrastructure in the ground. They've already invested a lot into their development before they go record. Like, they record pretty late in the process most of the time.
Speaker B: I think it's usually later. So as far as it in direction, I'd want it to be at least closer to the approval, not necessarily the recording.
Speaker Q: So that would— my plat, I think it's something we can have a discussion on, but maybe it's something we need to have a discussion and say, is it something that we can get on the front end of a final plat application and not wait clear to recording?
Speaker B: That's what I'm talking about.
Speaker J: Get it up.
Speaker Q: So final plat, I just I'm thinking about this real time, but we can talk through some of these scenarios. And then I think there's a little bit different discussion that we need to have about the commercial aspect of it, because I think they're kind of two different scenarios. So, but we can work through that.
Speaker B: Okay, that's why we have a discussion, so we can keep moving forward.
Speaker O: Sounds good.
Speaker L: You good?
Speaker B: Okay, and so the next one, we'll move on. I mentioned we got a lot of work and we keep getting behind, but I knew you'd get a chance to come up again too, but I hope you're at least nodding to say that you agree with the other stuff. And I wanted to get some input from developers, but we'll start with David and Deer Run.
Speaker J: Yeah, Mayor and Council, you saw this, oh, I don't know, 4 or 5 months ago, I guess. Developer Ivory Homes did make a few minor changes, want to bring it back to you and give you another review just again. Where we're located in the yellow, north of Quarry Road there where the new extension of Airport Road is. It is zoned currently Foothill Residential. And just to point out too, those 2 parcels that you see just on the above the red line where the Airport Road is, those originally in the proposal that you first saw, those have been taken out. Once staff You know, looked at the review of the resubmittal. We realize those are probably best served in Deer Run because of the road classification. Those cannot be accessed individually for lots. They are part of the Clearview Estates master plan right now, but certainly those can be removed from Clearview and included back into this project. Some of the points of discussion at the last meeting was the wildlife corridor. As well as the wash area. Wash area is still proposed to be under private ownership. You do have my redline version of the plan that we did look at, just so you can see our thoughts, my thoughts as we reviewed the plan. There are some thoughts on if this goes forward, some potential development agreement points to consider. And with that, uh, the applicant is here tonight as well. Uh, Brad with Ivory is, is present. Um, and so if you have any questions for me, uh, we can discuss that, or we can call Brad up now. And, uh, if you have any questions for Brad—
Speaker K: One, one of the questions the mayor had is how, how wide is the wash approximately?
Speaker J: How wide is the wash? Oh boy.
Speaker B: I'm looking just what the way it's drawn here, that as far as the wildlife corridor that's preserved was supposed to be that wash, right?
Speaker J: Yeah.
Speaker B: And I'm just wondering, is that— in some of the other areas we've preserved like 300 feet, and I'm guessing it's not 300 feet.
Speaker E: No, Mayor, that wash is not in the wildlife corridor.
Speaker B: Okay, that's what I was—
Speaker K: The 300 feet is probably something this way.
Speaker B: This way. That's right.
Speaker J: The applicant did already install culverts through the wash as well.
Speaker B: When I remember— so really, and I can ask Brad this, but just a question that I had, and it was— I think it was Councilmember Wood that I was talking to, and he's not here, so I'll ask for him maybe. In the original plans, there was a church site, and I know the wash was going to get maybe piped through there because that would become parking and things like that. And now there's no church site on here, whether or not it's because they didn't want it or whatever. Maybe that's the reason, but I thought that was part of that plan. And then he, he also asked what this green piece was on Airport Road. That's the park, I assume, for the park credits, or I don't know.
Speaker P: You ready for it?
Speaker B: Yeah, yeah, go ahead.
Speaker P: So, Mayor, you were not on the list for me to work through this.
Speaker B: Yeah, because I don't get a vote. I've said it twice today.
Speaker P: Yeah, you're, uh, you're off the list, I guess. But I, I met with all the current council members that are here on this plan, and, and we went over things. Is this the Pointer.
Speaker E: Does that one not work there?
Speaker P: Is this one a pointer? Okay, okay. So wildlife corridor is this piece right here, and I met with each of the council members individually. Um, the, the fence line, I believe it's right here, go— that goes north. So, um, Todd installed a fence, a wildlife corridor fence that actually goes north all the way here, channeling all the animals. The wash that they're trying to preserve is clear over here somewhere. And so, but your current map shows the wildlife corridor plan along this area right here. So this revised concept plan, per Councilmember Wood's recommendation, was to show as currently shown on your wildlife corridor master plan. So we've done that, we've shown that right here. Uh, the church site would sit— you, you see right here there's a line. I left that here just in case you wanted to see it. If that is dedicated by the Holbrook family at some point in time in the future, it would, it would take these lots out right here, but they are still considered part of the foothill residential zone. So we have shown those in this master plan, and at some point in time, if the Holbrooks dedicate that to the, to the church, then, then those would just go away at that point in time. But right now, we had to plan for what we can control, which was our direction in the last council meeting. Um, the, the 2 pieces up here, we don't control those, we don't own those, so we We were told in the last council meeting to pull back to show what we actually own. So we've done that, just pulled these cul-de-sacs back. If the city wants to work with us to acquire those 2 pieces, we're more than willing to work with you on that as long as it's a reasonable, fair negotiation. And then what we would do is extend those through and just move the cul-de-sac up. So we are willing to work with you on that. I think that's been clear from the beginning, but our direction was to to do a concept plan based upon what we control and what we own. So we've done that. The other thing that we had was that this wash right here, it was big discussion item. Everyone thought that was part of the wildlife corridor. It is not. It is yeah. It is not part of the wildlife corridor. We've confirmed it. There is no setback from the wash. The only ordinance that would apply, from what I understand, is the storm drain ordinance, and we plan to keep it open and, and maintain it. The question is, what is that width that we need to be able to allow the Public Works Department to come in there and maintain that channel?
Speaker A: And so—
Speaker E: Are you just going to do that by easement, Brad? Is that what you're thinking?
Speaker P: by easement. And then additional, what, what I would propose, we'd work with Marcus on something, is maybe doing a, uh, 20-foot setback from the top of the bank or something so that they could drive along each side.
Speaker B: I'm pretty sure we did set some code when Todd was here. It's like 75 feet from either the center line or something.
Speaker P: This is not the wildlife corridor.
Speaker B: Not the corridor, that's any wash, because—
Speaker M: Yeah, it does. There, there code in there, and it doesn't relate just to wildlife corridor. It's any wash. It's 75. You can't have a structure. Doesn't mean you can't have the lot, but you can't have a structure within 75 feet of the centerline or 50 feet from the top of the wash. That's not true. Whichever is greater.
Speaker P: We went through that with your staff before. It's not in the— or it's only in the wildlife corridor ordinance that that applies. Your other ordinances don't apply. So that is not correct.
Speaker B: I think that was our intent, so we need to look at that.
Speaker P: Yeah, it's not, it's not per your ordinance. And so, so what we've committed to though is to make sure that we give you what you need to maintain the channel, which would be 20 feet, a 20-foot building setback from the top of bank on either side of the channel. That's more than what you're—
Speaker M: It's in Title 17, Chapter 25, which is our residential Zones Code, uh, and it's, uh, I think— what's the section number? 050G. It says hillside development in sensitive lands.
Speaker P: This is not a sensitive land zone.
Speaker M: No permanent structure near natural washes shall be built in the watercourse plus 75 feet from the center of the flow line or 50 feet buffer on either side as measured out from the top of the bank whichever is greater, to be determined by the city engineer designee.
Speaker F: Right.
Speaker P: Marcus, though, the problem is this is not a sensitive lands overlay area.
Speaker M: No, it's— this is not overlay zone. This is any residential zone. Um, there's, there's, there's similar provisions in the commercial zone as well.
Speaker P: I think we had this analyzed already by your staff, and I don't think— and you looked at it.
Speaker M: Not in relation to— this has always been my opinion on— like, this applies across the board. I think there was issues as to whether or not this particular wash is actually natural. I think that's the issue that was analyzed. That's a separate question. Um, but if it is a natural wash, it would apply.
Speaker P: Read that language again.
Speaker M: No permanent structures near natural washes shall be built in the watercourse plus 75 feet from the center of the flow line, or a 50-foot buffer On either side as measured out from the top of the bank, whichever is greater, to be determined by the city engineer or designee. Additionally, no earthwork excavation or earth removal shall occur within the watercourse plus 75 feet from the center of the flowline or a 50-foot buffer on either side of the top of the bank as determined by the city engineer or designee.
Speaker P: But what does the first thing say? The heading of this section?
Speaker M: It's for what? The heading of the section is Generally Applicable Provisions. The subsection says hillside development and sensitive lands.
Speaker P: But that's—
Speaker M: So the sensitive land is the natural wash.
Speaker P: Uh, you don't define that in your code.
Speaker E: We already went over that.
Speaker O: That was one concern that Brad and I talked about.
Speaker M: You don't define that. If the wash is natural, This would apply. That's how I interpret it.
Speaker P: Yeah, I think—
Speaker M: So it doesn't mean you can't have it as part of a residential lot. It just means the house has to be 75 feet away from the centerline or 50 feet from the top of the wash.
Speaker F: This is kind of similar to the airport easement in Sage Valley where we can't build 80 feet into our— any permanent structures, correct? You can put a fence but not a permanent structure.
Speaker M: Yeah, I mean, that's related, I'm sure, to the airport being there.
Speaker P: So this is a residential structure?
Speaker M: This is any permanent structure. So I mean, whether it's an accessory building or structure or swimming pool, house. Yeah, a fence would be okay. That's exempted elsewhere, but yeah.
Speaker P: We met on this before and I don't, I think there's a, discrepancy there. And so we can work on that in the MPD and figure out something. I'm not opposed to coming up with something, but I don't think that specific language actually is applicable here. But we're willing to work with you on something that will work. So, and I don't know that it really matters because these lots are so big. I don't know if anyone wants to build within that distance anyway.
Speaker M: Yeah, I mean, my big concern would be somebody building like a shed or a swimming pool or something like that.
Speaker P: Or a sports court.
Speaker M: I think it's easy enough to site the actual house itself within the allowable building area.
Speaker P: So I think we could do some kind of language that makes it so it's not in conflict in the master development plan.
Speaker B: I don't think there's any issue with the The plat, maybe. I don't know. We're going to have to look at it. But all it said, this building envelope, the dotted line, that envelope might be here, which is still plenty of room to build the house.
Speaker E: Oh, yeah.
Speaker B: And they just can't build the sports court or the barn or the whatever. So I don't think there's an issue. Just, they didn't even know that the code says they can't build anything 75 feet. Both the builder or the owner in the future, 70 feet from the center line or 50 feet from the top of the curb. I would think Santa Clara and places in southern Utah wish they had a similar code. I think that's why we— if that's what we're trying to— and I don't think you want the liability of a house going down the river. So this isn't a river, but you understand what the code—
Speaker P: understand.
Speaker B: That's why I say intent, right? So yeah, I think you're okay. I just want to make sure that that was—
Speaker P: Yeah, I think, I think that's okay. The only other thing I think, um, we added this in, uh, trail connection to meet the code. And I think everything else meets all of your codes. Um, the, the one thing that we'll have to do in the MPD also is, is per your code, if we, if we give the city this wildlife corridor land, there the city council grants, uh, open space and parks credit, which we've included on our table. Um, and then this space right here would be, you know, big enough to be a park space. So I think those were the only major items. The rest of it I think we've already gone over.
Speaker E: Did you have any concerns with the, with the, the comments that David made on the blue lines? I don't know if you've seen that.
Speaker P: Yeah, I've seen those. Well, I haven't I haven't seen the blue line ones, but I've seen the staff report and I've talked to him about some of the stuff. I don't know if there's anything else that I'm missing. Dave, is there something I'm missing?
Speaker J: Yeah, I mean, I think I made the comment, a lot of that stuff can probably be put into the development agreement if you're comfortable with something like that. Obviously, there could be some unique situations here with this piece of property that can be answered. through that, through the DA. Yeah, you know, for instance, those 2 large lots up in the north, I think, great, allow the horses if someone's horses. Otherwise, those lots are just going to be weeds. Let's try and get something there that may be more useful on that property. Put that in the development agreement, you know, and you see my points there as well.
Speaker K: And so you were saying include the city land? Is that what you're talking about? The lots?
Speaker J: Those 2 lots up in the northwest corner? Very large, or at least—
Speaker A: yeah, let's allow—
Speaker J: and it's adjacent to a water report. Let's, let's put some horse rides on it.
Speaker K: Yes, agreed.
Speaker B: So those could have the equestrian overlays on them, for instance, on just those 2 lots could be overlaid in the foothill. Yeah. Uh, and, and potentially— not the way they're laid out, but I was looking at these ones— could potentially, you know, maybe, maybe this whole corner up here If I talked you out of one lot right there, you could have 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, you know, if these 2 were just one, it would be kind of a cute little equestrian corner right there. But I mean—
Speaker P: You could give me like 5 lots and then I'd take that one out and make it bigger.
Speaker B: You know what, I think we need to talk about that anyway, because I think— but yes. So I don't know if we're completely— if this train's been completely derailed, but But I know this was concept plan discussion. Have your questions been answered or your—
Speaker P: I think we can— we're at a point where we can work through, even though I really don't think your code is clear on that stuff. It's not like it's a deal killer and we can work through something.
Speaker B: Well, and I think that what I love about that kind of a discussion is if it's not interpreted right and we're not clear as mud, then maybe we need to bring it back and make sure that it's clear as mud. And because our intent is that, and maybe that's something that we can do, Marcus, is make sure that that is absolutely— that our intent is a little more clear.
Speaker M: Yeah, I mean, I think it is. I mean, I think the sensitive land being referred to is the wash itself.
Speaker B: But I think we agree with that.
Speaker M: I'm open to feedback in ways that we, you know—
Speaker B: Maybe staff didn't even interpret it that way. So let's be a little more clear.
Speaker P: So I've done this for a long time, right? So every city I've been in, if you identify hillside overlay area or a sensitive lands area, you have an associated map that accompanies the language so that it's crystal clear what you're looking at. So you know where a hillside overlay is, you know where sensitive lands are, and sensitive lands can be fault areas, they can be wetland areas or whatever, and you have a map So it's clearly identified what that area is and what's associated. Every city I've worked in has been that way.
Speaker G: If—
Speaker P: and you don't have that.
Speaker G: You have—
Speaker P: you do have one sensitive lands area, which is the something wash. What's the— what's the fill wash? You have a tick fill wash.
Speaker M: We have a ridgeline protection ordinance, to the extent you call that a hillside ordinance.
Speaker F: Yeah.
Speaker M: Or sensitive lands. We have obviously the wildlife corridor, to the extent that you want to call that sensitive. Um, I think we could map out our natural washes. I think that's a good suggestion.
Speaker B: Right. Yeah.
Speaker K: So I, I want to go back real quickly to the session. So this land, that's what's owned by the city, correct?
Speaker E: Yes, there's both parcels.
Speaker L: Both these?
Speaker K: Yeah.
Speaker B: So right over here.
Speaker K: I mean, I'll— as just my vote on that, I would like to see that sold to you guys and incorporated in this.
Speaker H: Perfect.
Speaker K: I mean, that's my vote. I don't know what the other city council members— I just don't see— it just seems natural to fit that. Otherwise, what are we going to do with that land? What's the city going to be doing with that 2 to 3 years from now, 4 years from now, 5 years from now? So I, anyway, I think we shouldn't—
Speaker J: That makes it really tough to develop if it's not included.
Speaker M: Right, right.
Speaker O: This piece of property.
Speaker P: I mean, that was kind of the intent all along, but we just need to do the deal. So otherwise, I think, I think the next step is move to get a draft development agreement. So, and I guess that starts with Marcus.
Speaker C: Yes.
Speaker P: Or our attorney.
Speaker D: Yeah.
Speaker M: So yeah, I mean, we have our template agreement for residential master development agreements. I think we would want to get a master development plan, all that. I mean, I know it's not much of a change from what this is, but get that process going because usually that's approved and then you do the development agreement based on what ultimately gets approved. approved as far as the master development plan goes, because that's what forms the basis for the MDA.
Speaker P: Yeah, and I think we've submitted that.
Speaker J: Yeah, I mean, at this point, can we include the master development in the—
Speaker M: So is there an active MDP application?
Speaker J: Yeah.
Speaker M: Okay, because I know this is a concept plan review is what this is titled. So yeah, I mean, we can start working on that at some point.
Speaker E: Okay, great.
Speaker P: Just quick, with regards to water, for instance, I, I've banked 300 and something acre-feet. A portion of it would be assigned to this, but that's more than what I need for this. And so if I had to dedicate that right now, then that's a process to go through to split that up And what do I do with the leftover water? And and do I still bank it? So I agree with Scott that sometime during final plat is the easiest time to do all of that kind of stuff. So you know exactly what you're splitting off at the time, at the appropriate time. So if we can do it, even if it's the first of the final plat or whatever, but I like the banked idea. I'm fine with that, and I like I like that we submit. Our estimation of what the water needs would be, because I believe that, like for speaking for Ivory Homes, we do all water-wise landscaping, and I think you over-exact when we do that kind of stuff because we're dedicating as if we weren't doing water-wise. So we're giving you way more water than than we should be because we we do. We require water-wise landscaping on everything we do. So, so anyway, I like that idea. Just going back on, onto the previous conversation.
Speaker B: I wanted your comments on that. That's why I knew you guys were here. And we're trying to make something work, and we're not the experts on everything. So I want to make sure it works for everybody.
Speaker A: Do you have anything?
Speaker D: No.
Speaker B: Any other questions or comments on this one? You're good?
Speaker E: All right.
Speaker A: Okay.
Speaker B: Thank you. If you hang out for a minute, I have some questions for you before we go into closed session. So I don't know if you're taking off.
Speaker E: How long is it?
Speaker A: I hope—
Speaker B: you've been here. We're not very far along. Next one. Thank you. Ready? The Harmony Phase A.
Speaker L: Robert Hobbs. Just southwest of us over here in the Harmony Project, Flagship Homes has approached the city about trying to seek from you your opinions on a design exception that they would like to introduce into their, uh, current proposal coming to us soon as a site plan and plat. Here particularly is the property in question, 3.63 acres. If you look back at the master plan, you'll see over on the eastern side, the right side, the location where we're talking about that was designated for multifamily development years ago. Their predicament that they have arises from a code change that we passed a couple of years ago or so. That was a reactionary code amendment to a development that came through with a series, if you recall, of townhouses in various buildings. But all of the project was accessed by private service drives. So not streets, not streets developed as private and therefore meeting public standards, but rather service drives. So this amendment that you see on the screen now was put forward and approved such that such situations—
Speaker J: I'm sorry—
Speaker L: would not occur in the future. So now, as it says in the code, townhouse buildings in MF-1 and MF-2 zones— and staff believes this project is suitable for an MF-1 zoning status— shall completely front or butt on and be accessed via streets, not service drives. The applicant had originally thought of doing condos down the southern end of the project site that you see displayed in this image. Now they would like to propose townhouses. Staff is pleased with that. They have a concept plan shown to you, and expectedly, they're here— or have a representative here tonight to talk about this and make a pitch for it. Staff has noted that they have in this drawing where you see Lulu Lane towards the southern or bottom portion of the screen, you have Lulu Lane being a service drive and you have a series of parking spaces, ostensibly guest spaces, all along there. The guest space count that they need for all this that's up here in the north— 1,000. Seems to be roughly 39 spaces when you figure one per every three units. Each one of those assumed to have two spaces also in a garage. This lower portion here, based on the quantity of structures building or building units, sorry, needs less than that at 23. So 62 total. Instead of Lulu Lane being an overbuilt service drive, our code would. Push them into making this into a street. So either 51 feet wide, right-of-way edge to right-of-way edge, if they were to follow what's been done already in Harmony, or if they meet current standard, as the development agreement calls for in 2 places, 2 paragraphs, 59 feet. They could have 59 feet along there and this 82.5 feet of depth, if you will, north and south, up and down, and then have a bank of 9-foot-wide parallel parking spaces and still fit that in that envelope, expectedly. The setbacks for this design would have to be as follows: a 10-foot buffer along the future Walden Parkway, which is not yet built out. And then basically overlapping that, I guess, would be a 15-foot front setback since the fronts of these units would face south or towards the parkway, with the sides and rear having 15 and 30-foot respectively. offsets from neighboring buildings. So the question becomes then, if they're going to be rear-loaded, are they allowed to use a service drive here, or do we want them to put a street in? That's the big question they're confronting right now. And if they're here to talk about it, uh, this project, then invite them up to speak.
Speaker B: Any questions for staff, or have the applicant come up?
Speaker K: So I guess, how does this change the unit count? So it sounds like if they move forward with condos, they could do that. Is that right? And if they're changing it from condos to towns, is there a density decrease because of that?
Speaker L: Probably, but I haven't mapped it out to see. I expect that that's what they would be doing on their end.
Speaker K: And is there— it reminded me, so Walden Parkway, is there going to be a fence along Walden Parkway as well?
Speaker L: There should be.
Speaker K: And so you're fronting something that goes right to a fence.
Speaker L: Yeah, unless there's some kind of waiver given by council like we did with the Parkway Townhomes, if you remember, Parkway Fields rather, where they end up with a 3-foot-high rail fence in lieu of something like a wall. But again, that's a discretionary call. So yeah, anyway, something to consider. Any other questions?
Speaker D: No.
Speaker L: Sorry, I should have asked. And thanks, Zach, for the new word I learned tonight, that financial chain leveraging. The financial chain leveraging word. That was fun after all these years.
Speaker B: Yeah, if there's no questions for staff, we'll invite the applicant. And did you have questions? You said start. You don't want to start?
Speaker H: Yes.
Speaker B: Okay.
Speaker A: All right. Hello everyone. I'm, I'm Luke. I'm with Flagship Homes here. Luke McComb. Um, yeah, so I think, I think the first question that I kind of heard earlier was the unit count, kind of addressing that.
Speaker B: Can I—
Speaker A: okay. Um, the condo plat that we have here that's recorded is, um, 9 total condos. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, and they each have 10 units each, so it'd be 90. This new plan has 68 townhome units, so it is— I guess we are decreasing the density here.
Speaker K: And you're not able to transfer that density elsewhere in the project?
Speaker A: Um, I—
Speaker M: well, the development agreement There's no vested density in multifamily in the Harmony project.
Speaker O: Yeah, there we go.
Speaker E: So I drove down there today and just to look at it, and can you just confirm what I, I think I saw? Oh, is that thing even working? Probably not. Kind of those curb, those curb outs that are between the 2 buildings, it seems that those are existing. I mean, it looks like the asphalt's in and— and, uh, oh, last one.
Speaker A: Sorry, Ed. Right there.
Speaker Q: And these are—
Speaker E: I think these are in, right?
Speaker A: Uh, yeah, I believe just the west portion is in right now.
Speaker E: Just over, over here.
Speaker A: I used to have an aerial photo of what was currently built.
Speaker Q: Council Member Wright, we reviewed—
Speaker A: That's in the staff report.
Speaker Q: We reviewed this.
Speaker O: Yeah.
Speaker Q: And we looked at this, and you're right, the asphalt is in. The sewer and the water lines are all in.
Speaker O: Sewer is in.
Speaker Q: We talked to the engineering firm about this project. So really what shifts and what changes is, if you go back to the previous slide, is you just shrink those islands in between. Those become narrower, and it makes it so that the water line doesn't have to adjust. It's still outside of the buildable envelope and whatnot. And so from a utility perspective, it will work from what we've seen. It's just with that additional parking in the middle there, is that— are we going to classify that as a roadway? Like, that's the real question.
Speaker O: That's the crux of the matter for sure.
Speaker E: Yeah, I think this is a rock and a hard place. That's how I feel like this one is, because you have entitlements. I mean, you're entitled to build those, those condominiums, and you could bring those forward and do them, I'm assuming. But is your infrastructure put in to accommodate this, or is it put in to accommodate the condos?
Speaker A: Uh, well, part of the— and I can't really speak to this that well, that Tony Train, he's our engineer on the project, he can answer all the specifics on that. But from what I understand, the current, or this townhome rendition that Tony has put together, helps mitigate some of the already installed infrastructure issues. And so hence why this is the design that he ultimately chose. Originally we had it with the stem driveways.
Speaker C: And then we—
Speaker A: that's where we read through the code and we couldn't do the stem driveways. And so we switched it to this design right here.
Speaker E: What's the stem driveway? I don't know what that is. What does that mean? Say it again, Rob. Step up and say it so people can hear you.
Speaker L: Basically, it's just an offshoot. It's just a stub driveway, like a little common drive that comes down off the main drive. So you'd have a bunch of those coming down in.
Speaker E: I'm just trying to think, how is this going to function? Because I think you are between a rock and a hard place. I mean, our code says you need to put a— that, that, that our multifamily needs to be accessed from a public street, right? You're not going to be able to do that here unless Walden Parkway is built with, with these specifically. Because you're not going to be able to convert Lulu Lane to a public street. I mean, you're not going to be able to meet that standard, I don't think. And I mean, I'm, I'm making some assumptions here based on what I've seen and what I'm hearing. So I think the question really is, is the— does the council have a willingness to find a path forward to do this instead of just moving forward with the condos with the existing And even the condos, you can't really build 'em 'cause you can't access 'em with this road that's required because the code changed. That's what I'm hearing.
Speaker L: Councilman Wright, one of the questions you might ask too in such a situation as this is how would it look if we had a public street there versus this in terms of overall width? Here you're looking at 24 feet of backup and then 20 feet for parking bank or stall set, and then you've got the landscape island, and then you've got another Presumably minimum 20-foot-wide service drive. So you're actually wider than a street. Now you've got some landscaping down the middle of it.
Speaker E: And Rob, that's kind of where I was going. I mean, I was trying to— I was kind of laying the groundwork to just bring— when I went down and looked at it, I just thought, well, what— look, he's asking to change it from condos to townhomes. He's looking to reduce the density. I don't know what we do with the— because the front of that, the, the unit is going to face Walden Parkway, which is just dirt. There's nothing there. I mean, there— and there's no sidewalk. There's no— I don't know how you're going to access the front of that. Walk through some— walk through the dirt? I mean, you're going to come into the garage and you're going to come in through the garage door, a man door that comes in off of the garage. I think that's how people are going to access these. But trick-or-treaters are going to be running through the mud to, to come ask for a sucker, right? I mean, so I'm looking at that, I'm just thinking, how can we mitigate that? And our code will require a masonry wall along Walden Parkway. And to your point, Craig, I mean, what is that going to look like when it's built, built out? Do you want your front of your house facing a block wall? I don't. Can you flip these things around? I, I mean, I don't know. I don't know. And I don't want to change your design. You guys have obviously already been through this. I'm just wondering, are there other options that we haven't discussed.
Speaker A: Well, the, the flipping them around, then you would be— you can't be loading on the Walden Parkway, um, just because of the requirements there. You're, you're saying— are you saying like a private drive?
Speaker E: I'm just wondering why you can't have the front of the townhome facing the interior of the thing. I mean, it would require a change of design is what it would require, where the garage— you, you come in for And maybe you can't. Maybe there's not enough room to do a garage and a door, a man door. I'm asking all these questions you guys have already evaluated. I'm just thinking, how do you solve this problem? And I'll just tell you, I'm inclined to say build this and let's do something with the access to Walden Parkway there. I mean, that's the problem.
Speaker K: Are you putting in like multiple gates? But these are too close together.
Speaker E: What's the distance, Rob, from the property line to what will be the right-of-way for the street to the south? There's going to be a piece of no man's land in there somewhere, right?
Speaker L: So, Councilman Wright, the one that I know of without looking it up is when you head from the— basically the property line down to this line, you've got 82.5 feet.
Speaker E: So what I'm wondering is what— because I'm making an assumption that So you're saying that this is the right-of-way that is shown here that will eventually exist, um, on Walden Parkway. Is that accurate? Because there's really nothing to gauge it on currently, because that's what it is. It just— it's just— it's all of this in, and there's still a bunch of field and dirt here. Gosh, I don't know.
Speaker F: I think you're right. We're probably going to have to rethink through the front of the townhomes. Maybe have some shorter gates, shorter wall.
Speaker N: I don't know.
Speaker E: I mean, maybe— look, maybe the way you do it— I'm making an assumption here because I don't know. This is going to be accessed off of Walden Parkway at some point in time. Once that connection can be made. Is that accurate?
Speaker A: Uh, yes.
Speaker E: And it will serve as an access point to all of this multifamily. So I'm wondering is if we can't— um, I don't know, I, I mean, I'm, I, I've been thinking crazy ideas today. I'm sorry, I just am throwing all this out. I'm just going to be quiet. But I'm wondering if we can't come to some sort of an agreement to put some sort of a a nice entry there so that we, so that we can contemplate that this becomes a future entrance to this development, that you guys take responsibility to put that in so that, so that we can feel good about not leaving this, this dead space area between your development and whatever that public right-of-way is. I, and I, I don't know what that costs. I don't know what the financial impacts are So you're talking about—
Speaker A: let me see if I can use this. Do I have the wrong one?
Speaker E: Here's one.
Speaker A: So you're talking about like adding some landscaping, some landscape features right on here?
Speaker E: Yeah, landscaping and some short fence, something that makes it feel like an inviting entry into the development.
Speaker A: Yeah, I like that.
Speaker E: So that it—
Speaker P: Little gates?
Speaker E: Whatever. Little swing gates? Just something that says this isn't an afterthought. And then we're gonna have to decide what's gonna happen here with that block wall.
Speaker A: So you're— yeah, so, well, what was the 3-foot pony wall that was talked about?
Speaker E: Yeah, Rob said that.
Speaker L: Yeah, I think. The Parkway Fields had a 3-foot fence that was put in place in a condition like this. I'm wondering, question for you, would it be viable to have your 10-foot landscape buffer here, then a service drive in the back like an alley-loaded product, then front these, push them forward, and have a street out here?
Speaker C: Yeah.
Speaker L: And then have a regular wall there?
Speaker A: I like the sound of that, actually. I think the main reason why I think Tony designed this one was because there's an existing sewer line. Something about the existing sewer line That has been put in.
Speaker C: I don't think it's—
Speaker A: I don't know what the status of it is right now.
Speaker Q: Yeah, there's sewer on one side of those parking aisles, and then there's water on the other, and they're already installed. And so I think that they were trying to work within the parameters so that those utilities didn't have to be tore out and reinstalled.
Speaker E: Will you tell us what your suggestion was, to flip them around? Say that again.
Speaker A: Uh, wait, oh, I didn't— sorry, I forgot totally what I was putting the service road on that. Yeah, this is your mic on. Well, what Rob was saying, right, was the 10-foot, right, 10-foot lands or some landscape buffer right there, and then a service drive, and it would be what, 26-foot or minimum 20, but if fire needed 26, then 26.
Speaker E: So is that how you're going to access the townhome into the garage? Will the garage be on that Another option.
Speaker L: And then front them back towards the street to meet the code. And Lulu Lane becomes a street with some parallel parking spaces long enough to accommodate the guest parking requirements.
Speaker E: I'm going to tell you, I mean, these are really part of this overall development, and I hate to see them get segmented off here because it's almost like they've turned their back on the rest of the development. They're not part of it. That's part of why I went down there to see them. See it. I thought I want to get a lay of the land and get a feel for what this is going to look like as a community. And so personally, I like the idea of flipping them around because now they're facing inward, and then you're going to have this border along Walden Parkway. And so what if there's a 10-foot buffer there? Maybe, maybe there's some way to finish that out when the road gets built, right? Maybe you can talk to your neighbors to the south and and figure out something that works. And I've said plenty now, Mayor. I'll be quiet.
Speaker K: I hesitate to have these front Walden Parkway because of the fencing issue that we're going to run into, because I want a uniform fence along that. Um, anyway, I sort of prefer this other potential alternative.
Speaker F: Yeah, there's a— the ability to flip them the other way, that makes the most sense. And then It is uniform. That's a good point.
Speaker K: But I would also say, given that it's changing from condos to towns and decreasing density, I do think we would want to try to work out something.
Speaker E: Yeah.
Speaker J: And I—
Speaker E: last thing, I promise. Lulu Lane, I mean, I think that's really the only way you're going to be able to access these. And the fact that it doesn't meet our current code is because it switched midstream. I get that.
Speaker A: And I think we have to have at least some sensitivity to that as we consider So I guess what I'm hearing is from, from the comments and the feedback is have some sort of landscaping here and then put the access drive right here, 20-foot to potentially 26-foot. And then the units would essentially sit right here with their little walkway paths onto Lulu, sort of. Yeah, that— I think we can make that work.
Speaker E: Staff okay with that?
Speaker C: Yeah.
Speaker B: Wasn't one of the issues that the water lines—
Speaker E: That's what I was— that's right.
Speaker A: Yeah, that was—
Speaker H: that's—
Speaker B: and yeah, I mean, in all honesty, and this is up to you guys, but if that water line has to move, that's— if they put it in ahead of time, that's It is what it is, right?
Speaker Q: I think really what we're looking at is we're trying to convert a parking lot into a residential roadway, and it's just not working. And as staff, if it's going to come in as a roadway, we'd rather see it as a roadway so we can maintain it as a residential roadway. There's going to be conflicts with, you know, flipping it and having a back drive. I was just over here talking to Brandon. Sounds like if it's a townhome unit, we'd require garages. Garages can't front on collector roads. So there's a bunch of things to work through here. Whereas if it was like an interior of this development, it'd be maybe a little easier to figure out. But there's just some complexities with it.
Speaker L: And that's where the— with the garages fronting on the collector road, so we wouldn't put them facing directly out. Well, let me rephrase that. We wouldn't have it to where they're accessing directly off those. That's what that is there for in principle. But if you have an intervening service drive like a frontage road, that's one option. The other option is do something else with Lulu or leave it.
Speaker E: How do you feel about using that home down there?
Speaker K: Maybe we need to brainstorm with the engineer, 2 or 3 of us, a couple of us and the engineer and staff, and try to reconfigure.
Speaker B: Yeah, I don't even know how to lead this one forward because I just—
Speaker E: I think there's some real benefit in just going down and looking at it so you can get a feel for what's on the ground. was much different than I anticipated it would be when I went there this afternoon. So that would be my encouragement to the council.
Speaker B: Well, and the question is, if it is a parking lot, not a road, then for sure it's not maintained. They got to maintain it, right?
Speaker E: Snow removal. It's a parking lot, and there's tremendous slopes down to the sewer. I mean, it's already— it's steep to the, the, the low point of the drainage, right? It's— yeah, there's a lot of challenges here.
Speaker B: So to me, and I, I just don't see us solving this here. Maybe some— the encouragement that I could give is that just like Brad Mackey's done is go 2 by 2 or meet with the council and try to come up with— and Rob, you could even accommodate those meetings so that we get— keep staff on board. I don't, I don't know.
Speaker E: Mayor, the hard, the hard thing for me is I know staff has looked at this. I mean, I, I saw this DRC. I know that they've wrestled with this just as we have, and I don't want to speak for them, but my— what I left with is that they don't have a good solution as to how to do this.
Speaker B: Well, I mean—
Speaker E: Is that a fair statement, Rob?
Speaker L: You know, maybe it's improper to throw this out there, but candidly, if I were sitting up there, I'd be tempted to approve it as proposed and have the units flipped around facing Lula Lane, let Lula lane be an overbuilt service drive. I drew the attention, I think maybe during that meeting, if not some other time, to a place I know of in another city that is in a commercial setting. It would be like busier than downtown here, certainly. And you have an intersection there, a major intersection. One of the roads, Midland, comes right off of the interstate and is crossed by another pass-through arterial. All the different road segments there look like commercial right way. Howbeit, that one of them, the 9 o'clock position, if you will, that entire thing, even though it looks like a big street with sidewalks, landscaping, all the marked lanes, etc., it's nothing but a service drive.
Speaker E: Private. But isn't one of the challenges who's going to maintain it and take care of it? Because the city doesn't want to do that. I mean, that becomes a real challenge for the city.
Speaker L: Yeah, it's just— just make it HOA like everything else. It's like that.
Speaker E: So maybe that's part of the solution, is to just say the city is not going to own this This is going to be a private street, which we don't do, and we're just not going to mess with it, and you're going to take care of it as a, as a, as a community.
Speaker B: But this is, this is what I'm— and I hate to be a hard guy, I just— and I, again, I don't say, but if it doesn't meet the code, I understand entitlements, and we say you can have 500 homes, but if you can't build them and can't meet the code, then you only get 480. Like, if, if he can't meet the code, then it— then he can't build it. Right? That— did we just—
Speaker E: Well, I think he can't meet the code with his existing plat.
Speaker B: Then he's got to change the plat, right? I mean, that's what I'm saying. If it's not going to work, then you've got to start over.
Speaker L: Part of the problem, to remind us though, is that this is kind of a— the code change came about in the midst of, and in response to the project, in the midst of this build-out. So what you see on this screen to the north of the site This is basically built out. Then you have this almost afterthought standalone, mind you, parcel, right? It's its own property. And now we're trying to marry it into that, and it had a preexisting condo arrangement. And trying to meet this code is where the issue is. So maybe it's a code amendment, maybe it's a development agreement, maybe it's. Too bad, so sad. Build what's required by code.
Speaker R: It's—
Speaker L: but that's—
Speaker E: I mean, I think that's why I told them to bring it. They were like, we don't know if we want to bring this to council. I said, we need to hear what the rest of the council members think. And I've dominated the conversation, so I'm done.
Speaker M: I don't—
Speaker F: oh, sorry, you're good.
Speaker G: I don't have a ton new to add because all the questions and concerns that have been shared are all the ones that I have. But I also think that this is a really important point as we've been talking about the process for water dedication and all of those other things that we've talked about today and in all the rest of our meetings. This is why we need to get the code right so we don't run into issues like this in the future. The process for approval is important because of stuff like this.
Speaker F: I think we need to find a solution here. Um, and I appreciate the reduction of 22 units. That's great. That's a good positive step. If there is a path forward to flip them the other way, as Council Member Wright pointed out, where their front doors are directing their neighbors, and we may have to make some exception that allows us to have a uniform wall, that'd probably be my priority to work down that path if possible, if that works with the water and sewer. I think we try to find a way to engineer that. Not ideal, but the code changed mid-course, and that's unfortunate.
Speaker B: All right, I don't—
Speaker O: I, I think there— that there's some options that I, I think you should that we should meet. I think staff should get with Flagship again. There may be some opportunities to move some lines around or reorganize some things and still get something that works for them. So I think Brad and I'd love to— and Ron would love to get together with them again and with Tony Train and try to work this out.
Speaker L: And if council can offer any, at least conceptual or guiding principles That would be helpful. So if there's any preferences you have, we'd like the units to face this way or not, or we want a service drive, we don't care, that's— it'll help, you know, direct us on what we talk about.
Speaker F: So principle would be to face the other way, facing the north, and service drive in the back. I think that's what we're talking about. All right, well, maintained by the HOA.
Speaker E: The road, the Lulu— Yeah, for me that's going to be key. Lulu Lane has to be maintained by the HOA, um, and the city's going to obviously need easements in there to deal with sewer and water and everything else. And I— we need our— we need our engineering and public works department to take a good hard look at this, and if something needs to move, it's going to need Perfect.
Speaker B: Thank you.
Speaker L: Thank you.
Speaker B: Appreciate you coming. And we'll, uh, looks like there's still more work to do. So thanks, Rob. This next one, I know, uh, Lacey's going to help us with this, but one of the things is I know next week we're going to have on our agenda a wildlife corridor and potential naming. But as we were talking about preparing a resolution, we didn't know what name it was. So there's a few options and different things we want council to, uh, weigh in and, and let us know as we prepare that, what that, uh, resolution that we know what it is that we're writing. Anything to add, or did I still—
Speaker D: No, that is it.
Speaker H: Um, I— it did bring to my attention, Natalie looked at the previous, um, council meeting, and, uh, Council Member Wright said Todd Ablock Memorial wildlife corridor. So I know that that was also—
Speaker E: that's the only question that I would say is, do we want to add the word memorial in there or, or not? I don't, I don't have strong feelings one way or the other, but I, but I think it makes sense because that's what it is.
Speaker B: Well, and I, I'm trying to remember, I think it was Brad, or we've talked about this a number of times in our, in our staff meetings, is it the— because potentially, and we're waiting for a bridge, and there's one time we were talking about just naming the bridge because it'd be more visible and you put a sign up, uh, or do we do the whole corridor, but how do you really recognize it? Um, you know, he, he was instrumental in helping us move that forward, at least on the bridge. Do we want to wait and name the bridge, or is it 2 different names? Or, you know, that's what we were talking about.
Speaker F: I would drop the, the word memorial. It's obvious that it is a memorial by putting some— somebody's naming it like Cory B. Ride just to shorten it up.
Speaker N: Cory B.
Speaker E: Ride Memorial Highway and Cory B.
Speaker G: Ride Memorial Park.
Speaker F: Is it the Cory B. Ride Memorial?
Speaker G: Yeah.
Speaker F: Is the memorial in there?
Speaker G: Yeah. And that's why I think we need to keep it consistent.
Speaker E: Memorial.
Speaker F: Okay, I stand corrected. I would just shorten things up and just call it the Todd A. Black Wildlife Corridor.
Speaker C: Well, call it Todd.
Speaker E: And, but, and Mayor— yeah, we, we Todd for Todd for short.
Speaker J: That's funny.
Speaker E: And Mayor, you ask— I think you ask a really good question. And at least in my mind, I think whenever that wildlife bridge gets built, I think that's where it should be recognized with some text of some sort, some lettering. But I think in the meantime, any public access point could have just a small, you know, aluminum street sign, for lack of a better term, that just recognizes that you're entering it and it just recognizes his name.
Speaker B: Well, and you know as good as anybody, I like what Lehi does with those memorial— they have a company over there that builds those little—
Speaker E: Yeah, I'm not doing that for the city. That would be a conflict of interest. But I've been doing that for Lehi.
Speaker B: Those historical markers, I think, why wouldn't you— you said streetside, why wouldn't you put a horse—
Speaker E: Well, you could do that. I mean, there's a budget that they've set aside for that. I think we get started and at some point some future council may choose to do that.
Speaker A: But yeah.
Speaker B: And it might be some future business owner that's over there by—
Speaker E: Maybe there might be a guy that helps with it when he's no longer serving here. We'll see.
Speaker B: So I knew that— I knew this was going to be easy and it was just something that I was like, hey, throw that on there real quick. Uh, are we settled that that's the name and that's where we're moving forward? And, and one, just like I've asked developers to help us with this. I know we have one of our most passionate wildlife people here. Is— I'd want to ask, is that what was intended? And from, from the community, comfortable with that name?
Speaker E: Okay, Memorial or not? Yeah, okay, Memorial. Okay, we're taking a poll from the audience. Yeah, thumbs up, thumbs down.
Speaker B: I mean, I want to get it right as best we can and If it's not right, somebody will change it, but we do our—
Speaker E: But I think it's Todd A. I like that because it, I mean, it's specific to him and what an awesome thing. I'm excited about that.
Speaker B: So is that clear how we move forward for next week? Okay, good. Anything else on that one? Okay, I was gonna mention real quick, Councilmember Whiting has stepped out. He might be back. Maybe send him a link just in case he could jump on the phone. But his daughter's a senior at the high school and getting some awards tonight, I think specifically for soccer. So congratulations to his daughter. Got his priorities straight. But he definitely— I told him, I said family first when he asked me about leaving. I said you leave when you gotta leave. So he's taking care of some business and might join us here in a little bit. here in a minute. We do have a lot of closed session items. I'm not too worried about because I know we're also gonna probably go back into closed session after the meeting. So we try to get back here as close to 7 as we can. I'm committed to be here at 7. I'm gonna say that. And then we'll have to— whatever we don't get to, we'll get to later. So real quick, the rest of our agenda should be fairly simple. But just for the consent items, I wanna make Make sure I get my pages right. And I think I skipped your stuff too, Ben. Did you have any updates?
Speaker C: Only that with the Utah City Management Conference, I'll be out of town tomorrow and Friday, but available by text email.
Speaker G: And maybe this came in an email and I missed it, but I know that originally there was some additional context that staff wanted to provide about the whole tree gate with UCCU site plan, and I'm wondering, did that get settled, or is there anything else we need to do with that? Mickey would know. She knew exactly what I was talking about.
Speaker B: Is this something we're supposed to do later? I'm trying to get this It's in the consent agenda. Oh, okay. Well, that's what I get.
Speaker E: Like, wait a minute, listen, but I'm not there yet.
Speaker H: So for the trees, they're, they're good. They're set. Planning Commission had placed some restrictions on their approval that I don't believe that they could after following through with it afterwards. So I just wanted to make sure you guys were aware of that before we presented it here.
Speaker G: Thank you, because I was sitting in the Planning Commission meeting going, oh boy. Yeah, so I'm glad that—
Speaker D: okay.
Speaker G: Thank you.
Speaker B: So I was going in order, but stay here 'cause we're on that item. Is there anything else on 12A that—
Speaker E: Yeah, I have a question, Mayor, and it's really just this, Mickey. I want to make sure I understand the drive-through direction. They're going to come this direction to the south, they'll turn to the west and then turn back to the north and, and then swing around almost a 180 and come at kind of a south, southeast direction. It goes in an easterly direction through the drive-through, right?
Speaker H: I'm horribly directionally challenged, but if you see the peninsula points north.
Speaker E: Can we pull it up and I'll show you? Because it doesn't indicate where it goes, but I'm making an assumption here. I'll ask my question. And, and then the question that I really have is this: I'm concerned about headlight screening, and when I looked at landscape plan, it looks to me like it's too sparse to act as a good headlight screen.
Speaker H: They indicate a 3.5-foot height Berm around it.
Speaker E: That was what I needed.
Speaker B: Brandon, can you pull it up maybe? Who's got a computer?
Speaker C: You—
Speaker B: whoever's working on—
Speaker E: I don't, I don't need you to do that. Yeah, if it's got a berm in all of that area so it's not— those lights are not going to shine back at people that might be taking the road to the south and/or to the— what is, what is the roundabout that we're ripping out?
Speaker H: Yes, and I did look at that specifically and they did say indicate a 3.5-foot berm plus the landscaping.
Speaker E: Perfect. That's all I have.
Speaker B: Okay, we're— Natalie is not here, right? We're recognizing the class of—
Speaker G: Are we gonna have a dress rehearsal of that?
Speaker B: That's why I'm asking if we got a map of which way we're supposed to go. We'll take care of that. Yeah, everybody's gotta go the right way or Natalie will get mad.
Speaker G: Stand on the right X.
Speaker O: We got to be here for.
Speaker B: Okay, uh, bond releases, Parkway Fields, good. The minutes, any corrections or comments on the minutes? Uh, we just talked about that one. 13A is the, uh, Second Amendment to— or Second Addendum to the Ranches Golf Course Agreement. And I actually— we probably start with this in closed session, um, because that is something that we're going to have to talk About when we come back. So that has to be in the next 30 minutes. Was there any, other than the closed sessions for land acquisition, any other questions on that one? Scheduled items, I know we're short on time. Is there anything we need to address on 14A or 15A and B? We'll just come back to those? We good on those?
Speaker L: Yeah.
Speaker B: Okay, then I think we got through most of what we needed to get through.
Speaker F: Mayor, I motion to adjourn to a closed session for the purpose of discussion of pending or reasonably imminent litigation, the character, professional competence, or physical or mental health of an individual, the purchase, lease, sale, or exchange of real property, a proposed development agreement, proposed project proposal, or financing proposal related to to the development of land owned by the state or political subdivision and/or the deployment of security personnel devices or systems pursuant to Section 52-4205-1 of the Utah Code Annotated.
Speaker G: Second.
Speaker B: Okay, we have a motion by Councilmember Hewish and a second by Councilmember Clark. Marcus, I have a quick question. Does this need to be a roll call vote or can it be all in favor?
Speaker M: Roll call.
Speaker B: Okay, Councilmember Clark.
Speaker G: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Ray?
Speaker E: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Herish?
Speaker K: Yes.
Speaker B: Thank you. Passes. At 6:19, 6:20, we're going into closed session. All right, 7 o'clock, and we will get started. November 4th, and we will call to— or we won't call to order just yet. I've asked Steve before we start if he'd lead us with a prayer. Heavenly Father, we are thankful to gather together tonight. We're thankful for the time that our elected officials and staff and residents and others take to be here and, and ask for thy guidance in making decisions for the city.
Speaker E: And, and please bless those in our community that are struggling.
Speaker B: Please bless them with comfort and Help, and please continue to help us and our various residents be guided to help those around us and serve where possible.
Speaker E: Say this in the name of Jesus Christ, amen.
Speaker B: All right, it is 7:01, and we will now call the meeting to order and thank everyone who's here to participate with us. Appreciate you coming. With that, we will start with the Pledge of Allegiance. And we've asked David Yuleberry, our safety guy, to help us with that.
Speaker P: I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
Speaker B: So to start off, I know this is kind of a 2-part, but is there any information items specifically before we go to Natalie?
Speaker E: I have a whole—
Speaker B: Go ahead. So that's why I'm checking. You go first.
Speaker O: You want me?
Speaker J: Yep.
Speaker R: All right.
Speaker C: There is a long list. Thank you so much. Okay, last week, Eagle Mountain City was announced and designated as a Healthy Utah Community. We appreciate all those who were involved in making that go forward. We know, Councilmember Clark, this was something near and dear to your heart, and seeing this finally achieved is a goal for Eagle Mountain City. Eagle Mountain City was recognized as a Healthy Community. This designation highlights our efforts to support residents' health and well-being through through community programs, resources, and opportunities to stay active. It's a whole designation that you have to go through in order to be able to get that and to recertify every 3 years. But it involves adding new programming and different things that we do as a city to try to enhance our residents' overall quality of life and their— the health of the community at large. Also last week, Eagle Mountain City made a designation and an acknowledgment that we are working on the creation of an aviation hub. Eagle Mountain City is exploring opportunities in advanced air mobility and aviation. Our partnership— our participation in the Zero Gravity Summit with 47G helped to connect the city with industry leaders and explore emerging transportation technologies. A lot of people ask, well, why, why are we interested in that type of thing? And I think it's important to designate that the majority of our residents leave our community each and every day, and they commute out of town, uh, to their jobs. And the more we can work to create jobs within our community, high-tech jobs, um, high, high-paying jobs, um, the more we can, uh, do 2 things: keep people local and off the roads, and that helps our transportation issues, and also to create a daytime population, which enhances our overall, um, uh, commercial base, and, and more businesses want to come to our community. So, um, that's a real benefit. And then aviation, um, we are co-located near Camp Williams. We want to be on the forefront of the future of that technology since it's already being tested, and drone technology is being tested in our community. And of course, for no other reason than we are the aviators and we want to support our local school as well. Um, this week, Meet Emmy, um, is our new bot, AI bot that can help our residents 24/7 on our website and through many other connectivity venues. So Eagle Mountain's new 24/7 AI assistant is here to help residents connect with their city. Residents can chat with her on our website or text hello to 855-SOEMI, 855-763-6633.
Speaker N: Thank you.
Speaker C: 643 to find city information, learn about services, report issues, and to get help in more than 70 languages. If a question needs a human touch, Emmy can pass the request along to city staff for personalized support. No question goes unanswered. Emmy is here for the city information— for city information and requests, not emergencies. Always call 911 in an emergency. And, and as this bot continues to become more and more educated with more and more information coming to it, it becomes, um, better and, and more, uh, able to answer questions for our community. Um, EM30— this is our 30th anniversary on December 3rd, and part of that, we have a treasure hunt going on right now. Um, we're celebrating Eagle Mountain's 30th anniversary with a community-wide treasure hunt. Residents can solve riddles, explore public locations throughout the city, and discover hidden prize boxes. We're updating our website, um, as treasure chests are found, and we'll celebrate the winners at our December 1st City Council meeting. And it's important to know a lot of them have been found. There's a few really hard ones to find, so look for those. They've all been found. Oh, they've all been found. So there is a lot of interest, and the community really came out to celebrate in that activity. They will be given gifts and acknowledged in a council meeting on the 1st. Um, the 3rd annual, uh, toy, uh, drive. Eagle Mountain, uh, Public Library is preparing for its 3rd annual toy drive, helping bring, uh, holiday joy to children and teens. Residents can donate a new unwrapped toy at the library through, uh, December 11th to support local families during this holiday season. And then we have Thanksgiving basket donations. Eagle Mountain Senior Center is accepting nominations for the 2026 Thanksgiving basket recipients. Residents can nominate an individual or family in the community to help ensure that they enjoy a warm meal this Thanksgiving. So submit nominations to our website at eaglemountain.gov. Some upcoming calendar items: we have Bag the Leaf program. This runs through December 18th with dumpsters available at 2 locations, Silverlink Amphitheater and the Pony Express Rodeo Grounds. Residents can pick up bags at City Hall, the Public Works Building, or Neighborhood Improvement Department. Bagging leaves helps prevent stormwater pollution, reduces clogging in drains, and lowers the risk of street flooding. As a reminder, the dumpsters are there just there for leaves and not trash. Residents can pick up 2 free dump passes at City Hall if you have trash items that you need to get rid of. Veterans Day is Wednesday, November 11th. Our city offices will be closed, including the library, on Veterans Day. We have a Veterans Day breakfast on Saturday, November 14th, from 8:00 AM to 10:30 AM at the Overland Barn, so we can honor our veterans. And lastly, we have a Turkey Trot. Registration is open for our annual Turkey Trot Thanksgiving morning. This race begins at 8:00 AM on Thursday, November 26th, at Corey Ride Memorial Park, and you can register at Anything else?
Speaker E: That's a lot.
Speaker B: It's gonna be a fun week. We got a lot going on. So, and, and I said this before, that Turkey Trot, man, the socks— you better get there early. That's all I'm gonna say. If you want Turkey Trot socks, get there early. And then just a question I have a question on those announcements too. I'm not 100% sure, but I think that Healthy City designation might have— the trophy or plaque might be at my house. Did we have a place we want to put that here?
Speaker C: Oh, absolutely.
Speaker B: I'll— I can't remember. Did you remember? Did you end up with it?
Speaker P: I think I might.
Speaker C: I think you have it.
Speaker B: Okay, so I need to get that over here so we can display it. Thank you. So the next one You're already ready, Natalie. This— and this is the coolest thing— is this the 3rd one we did, right? 4th one. I lose track. And I'm telling you, if you're a citizen, a resident here, and you haven't been through the academy, do it. It's awesome. All these graduates are going to tell you they learned a lot and they have a different perspective than Facebook now. So go ahead.
Speaker I: All right, uh, we'll go ahead and invite the council to come down in front while I give a quick explanation for those who haven't heard about the Citizens Academy. It is a 6-week interactive course. You come to the city once a week for a little 2-hour course, and you get to meet with our department heads, and they explain to you what their jobs are, how the different departments of the city interact with each other. You get to see some things you wouldn't normally get to see or smell, like our sewer treatment plant. That one's always a crowd favorite. Um, and it's just a really cool opportunity to get to know the city and to also get to meet people in your community. Um, before we go ahead and dive into reading their names, I just want to say that, um, as in recognition of getting— sorry, of attending and graduating from the Eagle Mountain Academy, these participants will receive a t-shirt which is special edition. You can only get it if you attend the academy. You'll receive a certificate and a pin, because as we work together to ascend together as a community, these individuals have earned their wings. And so you will receive your wings tonight. So, um, as we call each individual, please go ahead and come on up here to receive your certificate, and feel free to shake hands down the line. And then after we read your name, feel free to just kind of stand off to the side because we'll invite you back up at the end for group picture. All right, tonight we are recognizing the following: Ashley Barrett.
Speaker D: Tyler Bateman. Rob Burton.
Speaker I: Tyson Ayer. Amy Hart.
Speaker D: Katherine Jamison. Brett Jones. Evelyn Julian. Jonathan Monroe. Christine Montgomery.
Speaker H: Bob Peterson.
Speaker I: And last but not least, Shirley Peterson. All right, let's hear it one more time for the graduating cohort of Eagle Mountain Academy. The council, the council can go ahead and head back up, and we'll have the participants stand in front. Yep, go ahead and stand in the front. The council members will stand behind you.
Speaker E: Perfect. Thank you.
Speaker B: All right, congratulations. We appreciate you guys coming. I get to go to some of those classes towards the end. It's A little bit harder. I got too busy, but, uh, super fun getting to know everybody and participating. Um, the next item— we set aside a time— I got to slow down so I can talk. We set time aside for public comment. As a reminder, public comment is an opportunity for the community members to address the city council, and each speaker is allowed up to 3 minutes. If you wish to speak during the public comment portion, please complete a comment form in the back and bring it back to our city recorder over here on this side, to Lacey. Council members will listen but not engage in discussion during public comment. We ask that everyone remain respectful. Disruptive behavior, including cheering, booing, clapping, or comments directed at individual city employees, is prohibited. If you have issue or questions regarding staff or personnel, administrative staff will meet you in the foyer for a for further discussion. Lastly, public comment period is for items not associated with a scheduled public hearing. If your comment relates to a public hearing item, please wait until that item is called. Tonight's public hearings are on the agenda, 15A and 15B, which are land use— have to deal with the land use map and the Code 1768.85 regarding artificial turf. So we'll wait for those.
Speaker D: Thank you.
Speaker B: Any other comments? We will start now. It is 7:15, and I will open our public comment period.
Speaker G: Lacey.
Speaker H: Tiffany Ulmer.
Speaker R: Hi, Tiffany Ulmer. I recently, about a year ago, purchased a farm on Lake Mountain Road at the end of the long dirt road south of John Hancock. And recently the road conditions have become terrible. And I was trying to figure out what was causing them. I expect a dirt road to be a dirt road. I get that. But right now Lake Mountain Road is literally a lake mountain. I mean, you could probably see carp swimming in the big puddles. It's so bad, especially in front of John Hancock. And that made me wonder why we didn't have John Hancock finish building the road all the way to the edge of their property. It's only like halfway through, and that's the area that needs to be taken care of. It's muddy, it's foot-deep water, there's a water main thing that's buried that if you don't know it's there, you're going to hit it and damage your vehicle. So maybe we need to follow up with John Hancock and maybe have them finish that section of road that should belong to them, is who I'm assuming. Also, the road's getting worse because it has recently was relabeled as a construction entrance for one of the data centers. And so now we have data center traffic going down this dirt road, big vehicles. And it's really getting torn up. And the residents who've lived there before me and my farm for a year, they say that it's a lot worse than what it usually is. So if we can maybe check that out. I also reported trash such as a sofa, tires, and other things to the app. And the person on the app wrote back saying, hey, we're going to close this, but we'll take care of it. They still have yet to pick up any of the trash or that stuff. Um, it's a sofa. I can't pick up a sofa to take with me. So if we could just do something to help Lake Mountain Road out a little, I'd appreciate it. Thanks.
Speaker B: Okay, that's it for public comment. Is there anyone here that did not have the opportunity to speak? Seeing no one, at 7:18 we'll close the public comment period and come back to the council and I'll start over here on the island with Zach. Councilmember Hughes.
Speaker F: I'm on my own. I'm holding down the fort on this side of the dais today. Appreciate everyone coming tonight. Congratulations to those that just received their awards. We're always trying to educate residents. I've lived here over 20 years and there's a lot that I still don't know about our city. And I look at the infrastructure and all of the projects that we have going on and We get a weekly email from Ben Reeves, our city administrator, and there's usually 35, 40 projects on that. I mean, it's a long email of everything we have going. I just don't think people realize what that means when you're the 9th fastest growing city in America, not just in the state of Utah, but in the United States. Is it appropriate for me to address Tiffany Ulmer's comments?
Speaker A: You can.
Speaker F: Is that okay? So maybe just to follow up on, on that road. I have had a couple other people reach out to me regarding the data center traffic. I don't know if they're getting routed that way or why. It doesn't seem like it'd be an efficient path to take on a dirt road with a big truck. But I also personally, I, I had an issue earlier in my park where I was reporting tree stumps where the parks department had cut the tree down because they had died, and we reported that the tree had died, but they had just cut the tree, left the stump, and we have about 5 or 6 of those in our local park. When I reported that, they similarly closed the issue and it never got resolved. And I'm wondering what the incentive structure is for those that are responding to those app requests as they come through. Why are they closing them out? I think we should probably keep them open until they're absolutely confirmed done. In my employment, we have a process that we follow. We call it a double do, where the person doing the single do, the first person at the at the job, reports that it's complete, and somebody comes back after them and confirms that it was done correctly. So I'm wondering if we can evaluate what that process looks like within the city and not just close them out because as residents, you're expecting for that. It exists to report that and to take action for the city. And if we're closing them out, they're not happening. I would just be curious if that's something that we could maybe take a second look at. And just grateful for everybody that came tonight. Thank you.
Speaker E: Thanks, Mayor. Welcome everyone. Just wanted to report on the chili cook-off. I was going to win first place, but I didn't.
Speaker C: Me too.
Speaker E: So Councilmember Whiting took the first annual chili cook-off with the seniors, and he won, and Councilmember Clark took second, and I took third, and the mayor got honorable mention. But it was a lot of fun. We enjoyed it. I met the Petersons there at the chili cook-off, and I want to congratulate them. They'd only been in the city 2 weeks when they signed up to take the Citizens Academy courses. And I just, I just applaud that. I mean, they moved to a new city. They said, we want to understand what's going on and how do we get involved. And, and they, they've inserted themselves into things in the community. And I'm just grateful for people like them and to each of you that are here. And I'm grateful that Lake Powell got 14 feet of water over the course of the last week. I'm super grateful for the rain and just ask our residents to do all that you can to prepare for that extra rain. We're praying for it. We're hoping for it. And we better be prepared when it comes to divert it away from those areas we want to keep it out of. So, and I would, Tiffany, I would just, I would make one comment about John Hancock. I don't know the circumstances about that road, but my, I'm going to give you an assumption based on my experience. My assumption is, is the city probably could not compel them to do that, or we would have. And it probably belongs to someone else, or we can let staff answer that for you, but that's That's my assessment. Does staff know? Does anybody know about that that would be willing to speak to it?
Speaker M: State law governing school, specifically governing public schools like charter schools, says that we cannot require them to dedicate road or to build it out past essentially their entrance. So in this case, where there's, unless there's certain other circumstances that aren't applicable here. So in this case, where John Hancock's just kind of out there, and it's by, you know, approved but not built subdivision, and that portion of Lake Mountain Road, they could essentially have to build it to their last entrance to the school. And we can't, even though their property line goes further, we can't compel them to build out the road any further than that. And that's just a matter of state law.
Speaker E: Take that up with your Utah Legislative Corps group. They're the ones who can make that adjustment, and we've lobbied them to make some changes regarding the requirements for schools. Cities are very limited in what they can require schools to do, charter or public.
Speaker H: Awesome.
Speaker G: Thank you, Mayor. It's, it's always fun to see you guys here, and I love that you availed yourself of the Citizens Academy because it's a really cool opportunity to learn more about what goes on in our city. I wanna give some kudos to our staff. We're told through, like, the budgeting process and everything else that we need to try to do more with less. And I agree, that's what we have to do in our family budgets. And I like the creativity of finding technology to help us stretch our resources a little bit more. Thank you. And I think the ME AI is a perfect example of that because we're always trying to find enough employees to staff customer service and utility billing and try to find an employee who speaks the language of the person who's coming up and asking questions. And what's cool about this technology is for a fixed amount every year, we can have it in like 72 different languages and they can answer questions 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. And I think that this is going to be a neat way for our residents to get answers when they can't otherwise contact someone at the city. So I'm grateful that they did that, and I love that there's a text because I hate emailing, but that's a little thing about me. I also want to thank our veterans. With Veterans Day coming up, I'm so grateful for all that we have in our community all that we have in our country, and because of the people who've put everything on the line so that we can be at home safe with our families. I'm excited for the Veterans Day breakfast. That's something that the city has been doing for a really long time, and I— there's been some changes in the American Legion post recently, and our city event staff has just stepped up and didn't miss a beat. They're making sure that it comes forward and coordinating with Scouts in the community and our American Legion, what's left of it, and working to make sure that we still do a really cool veterans breakfast. So if you know someone in your neighborhood, please invite them to come to that. It's, it's for them and their families, and we really want to make sure that they have that opportunity to be honored by our community. Last week, some of us on City Council with our staff and our mayor got to go for what some people call a retreat or conference, but I call it a really long meeting, at the Utah League of Cities and Towns on Tuesday and Wednesday. And you start your day like at 7 in the morning up at the Salt Palace, and you go until like 4:30, 5 o'clock at night. And all day long there's classes, and there's classes so that our recorder's office can get certifications, And our communications team can see what's going on and learn from other comms teams in the city world. And it was a really great experience to go up there and to connect with other cities, to connect with some of our state leaders, and just to learn more about how to do this job better for you guys. While we were there, Jenny Taylor, who's the widow of Major Brent Taylor, who was a North Ogden mayor, kind of spoke to all of us. And in her remarks, she said— she was a schoolteacher at one time, and she said, I want you guys to repeat after me. And she said, I am grateful, I am gifted, and I have something to give. And she made all of us say it. And she went on to say that she wants us to be grateful because all of us ran for this position or applied for the job that we have, and we're grateful for it. And then she said she wants us to remember that we're gifted, that each of us has something different, a different perspective, a different talent. And that goes for the residents in our community too. You guys are gifted. You bring something different to us and help us become richer and better as a community. And then the last one is, I have something to give. And she just kind of said with everything that's going on in the world, what would happen if we all just leaned into the fact that everyone has different gifts and everyone brings something unique to our communities and to their roles here at the city? And I just thought that was such a good way to kind of crown what we learned up at ULCT. And I hope that each of you know how grateful we are for you, and we're grateful for your gifts, and we're grateful that you're here sharing your different perspectives and keeping us in line and challenging us to be better. And I just want to thank you for coming out tonight.
Speaker H: Thank you.
Speaker B: All right, thanks guys. And I just add a couple of things.
Speaker J: I—
Speaker B: one of my favorite crowning moments of the conference last weekend— I've met a lot of prominent people in my life. I know, you know, through some of the different jobs I've had, it's been really fun. But up there, I got to meet Frank Abagnale, and if anybody remembers him, Catch Me If You Can. Catch Me If You Can. Yeah, the guy that's— and I'm intrigued by a guy that's so smart that he could get all that fraud and stuff. I'm like, I couldn't do it, so teach me, right? No, but it was awesome. He was a cool guy and scared me to death.
Speaker E: But Mayor, let's make sure we tell— his purpose in coming was to help us learn how to secure ourselves better.
Speaker B: It was. That was cool. And he's just an amazing man, and I think that was fun. So I even took a picture with him, which is not like me. So that was fun. Just wanted to thank all the candidates. Yesterday was Election Day. That's why we're having a Wednesday night meeting. And everybody who put their name in and the results and for everybody that voted. So appreciate everybody that participated in that. And then I did also want to say, just this is something that I've been trying to work on. I haven't reported yet because I don't have an answer yet, but it's, it's It's just the stuff I do that maybe people don't see. But the data center traffic, not just what's going on on that road and the stuff like that, but traffic regionally. I've been working with the data centers to implement a bus route specifically for their workers. And that means I'm trying to locate parking lots in Lehigh and Bluffdale and trying to get places where they can kind of do a little park and ride and carpools to try to help us while we're building these roads. So There's a lot of funding that takes place, and there's obviously a lot of offsite stuff that I've been working through. I'm not there yet, but I just wanted to kind of preempt that to let everyone know it's not falling on deaf ears. We know what's going on, we're working, there's solutions coming, but it just takes time. And there are efforts that we're making to try to accommodate everything we can.
Speaker J: Thank you.
Speaker B: And then lastly, to the graduates, some of them have already snuck out, but man, that course is awesome. So congratulations to the graduates. With that, we need to get to business and get started. Before we go to our consent agenda, I think Marcus was gonna give us a rundown of item 14, let's see.
Speaker O: 13.
Speaker C: 13A.
Speaker B: 13A.
Speaker M: Yeah, so this is the agreement Agreement, uh, the second addendum to the Ranches Golf Course Agreement. Okay, so, uh, we are, um, have been pursuing a project to widen Ranches Parkway and looking to acquire right-of-way from the golf course to, uh, in order to widen Ranches Parkway. Uh, we're receiving, uh, MAG funding for that project. Um, so this agreement is the golf course, uh, essentially giving us the land in exchange as payment for debts that it already owes the city. And so it's approximately, I think, if memory serves, about 3.5 acres of land in various spots that we need as part of the Ranches Parkway widening project. The debts that they owe us relate to the initial purchase of the, of the golf course from the city. For those who may be unfamiliar with the history of that, the golf course was originally owned by the original developer of the ranches. It was then later sold to the city or given to the city, and the city then later contracted with the company to run it and then later sold it to that company, who then sold it to someone else to run the golf course. So that's kind of the history there. As part of the purchase price, the way that it was structured is based on net profits, and so that debt is still outstanding. It's not been fully paid off. And so this is a way for them to pay their debt to the city. There's some other debts related to utility bills and stuff like that that are also owing to the city. And so it's a way for them to pay their debts for things that the city actually needs, which in this case is land for the widening project. And so that's the nature of the agreement. It does also require us to pay for certain construction-related costs related to like relocating cart paths and things like that, golf course infrastructure that's being disrupted by the the, the purchase of this land. So that's kind of the nature of the agreement.
Speaker B: Okay, perfect.
Speaker A: Thank you.
Speaker G: Um, Mayor, um, and maybe I missed it, but also the funds will eventually be reimbursed by MAG because this is a MAG-approved project.
Speaker M: Yeah, yes, I, I didn't mention that, that the Ranches Parkway widening project is a MAG-funded project. So we're getting paid So it'll be reimbursed, but those costs are going to be reimbursed to the city. So, um, where, for example, certain utility bills that are outstanding, uh, city payments to that fund would be ultimately reimbursed from MAG because it's being used to pay for the Ranches Parkway widening.
Speaker B: Perfect. So with that, I'll come back to the other item, but let's take care of the consent first.
Speaker G: Mayor, I move that we approve the consent agenda.
Speaker A: Second.
Speaker B: Okay, we have a motion by Council Member Clark and a second by Council Member Huish, and we'll start with Council Member Wright.
Speaker E: Yes.
Speaker B: Council Member Clark.
Speaker G: Yes.
Speaker B: Council Member Huish.
Speaker K: Yes.
Speaker B: And Council Member Whiting.
Speaker K: Yes.
Speaker B: Okay, now that we've got through that, I want to come back at the top of the meeting. I was waiting to excuse people because I was trying to get, uh, Everything, figure out when we were getting here. So excuse Craig for the first part because his daughter got an award and I want to hear about it. But we just got through with the council report, so I wanted to come back to that so you could report.
Speaker K: Yeah, thanks for the patience for the public. So it was the soccer banquet tonight. She's a senior and there's an awards ceremony with that, and she did get one of the awards. And I appreciate that you gave me the opportunity to to spend that time with my daughter. It's her last moment of soccer for, you know, many years of soccer that she has been involved in. And, and so it was, it was awesome for me to be there. So thanks for giving me that opportunity.
Speaker B: Yep, thanks for joining us. And also wanted to excuse Council Member Wood, who's, uh, ill tonight, so we'll be missing him. All right, moving on then, uh, the next item, we'll go to our Resolution 14A. This is a resolution of Eagle Mountain city authorizing the land disposal application to proceed and directing staff to begin the notice and public hearing process for a portion of Utah County Parcel 382570108 designated as significant real property. And this is, um, Lacey.
Speaker H: Yes, it is. Good evening, Council. Um, so this application was prompted by a neighborhood improvement notice that came through regarding a cement wall that was constructed on city property to prevent runoff. I sent a video over to you yesterday for your review. A couple things to note before we jump into this: the city is designing a 36-inch culinary water transmission line that will run north and south within the city's existing easement along the east side of the parcel. The applicant is here and is open to an alternative agreement that would allow the city to retain ownership of the cement wall without proceeding with the disposal. The app— the applicant's here and staff is prepared to answer any questions, and I can pull up the map and a picture of the water right now.
Speaker B: Okay, yeah, if you would put that picture up or the video, whichever it was you're going to do. And in the meantime, uh, are there any questions for staff before we bring up the applicant?
Speaker L: No?
Speaker B: All right. Then I'll invite the applicant forward to tell us what's going on and explain the picture if you'd like, or plead your case. We need to turn your mic on. There's a little button there in the front. There you go, it's on now. Now you turn it off.
Speaker E: Can you hear me?
Speaker F: Hit it one more time.
Speaker A: All right, so I did— I didn't know about them putting a pipe in.
Speaker B: Did That's on the east side. And the Public Works asked when we talked about this in staff meeting if it went north and south in this easement, but it's actually— sorry, east to west.
Speaker A: It's coming down this picture, so down towards the floor.
Speaker B: From the other road to the north all the way. It is on— it goes this way. Yeah, okay.
Speaker A: So I've lived in this house since 2002.
Speaker B: So you can point at it if you want, if there's— if you need it.
Speaker A: Is this one?
Speaker L: Yep.
Speaker C: Okay.
Speaker A: Okay. So my backyard right here has been about 4 feet lower than this pathway right here. And the water run off of that hill, I'd say this area here runs straight down. It doesn't go that way. It doesn't go that way. It goes straight down into here and floods my yard. When we first moved there, we built a wall here. And a wall right here. And the water would just run off into our yard. And eventually that pathway along this edge was eroding. So the water would come off of it and it would erode underneath the pavement, the road base. And so we thought, well, we'll build a fence there. And we didn't believe the fence would do anything. It would just— the water would run underneath the fence.
Speaker N: Right.
Speaker A: So I had a bright idea of putting block there as a fence. And I put it on the city property up against the pavement, not knowing at the time that I put it on city property. And someone come and told me I built a rock— a block wall without a permit, and that's what I'm doing here now. So my proposal is to either, um, where we've improved the property because it is protecting the pathway, is we would either buy that piece of property from the city and leave the wall there, or We donate the wall to the city and leave it there, or we take the wall down and ask the city to help us with that water problem.
Speaker K: So with the wall up, has that helped with the water issue?
Speaker A: I provided a video and it's nasty. This happened in July, I think. It was just one of those hard storms that come through. But in the winter, it's that way every spring. The snowmelt and rain that we get, and when it rains when there's snow on the ground, it just floods. But yeah, that's kind of where we are. We're willing to purchase it from the city, and— Because it's really kind of an asset No use to anybody with that pathway being there. And the wall is more of a fence than it is a wall to us. Originally we were going to go 6 feet, but as we come down it just— we just made it— we just put that top layer, just continued it flat. Which makes it taller as it comes down to right through here. But yeah.
Speaker F: I'm just wondering if you could— we've got a lot of projects around the city. We'd love to see that wall all around our city. If you want to just keep going, that'd be great.
Speaker A: Well, I listen to your stumps and stuff like that that you have left in your city. I'm a— I went to a house aid program this morning to, to help people with homelessness. We donate our time to, to help other people. I'd be willing to donate time on top of purchasing to, to help other people in the city too. So—
Speaker F: No, I, I think that you probably found a solution. It seems like we still need to maybe get some kind of drain on the other side of that path, because eventually you'll just have that dirt build up against the wall. In my mind, we're in the process— my neighborhood, we're building a sign for our neighborhood on city property. We did get approval to do it, but the caveat was the city at any time could remove it, you know, if they wanted to. And that's just a cost—
Speaker A: Like an easement?
Speaker F: Yeah, we're just bearing it as a neighborhood to build it and putting in the labor and materials. And so I don't know, I think I'm probably more in the camp to just have it be donated to the city and leave the wall as is. But I do think we probably need to figure out that drainage issue anyway. And is there a good solution there?
Speaker A: Possibly gonna sell those— there's like 3 lots there that they proposed to put property on building. Yeah, we'd be interested in purchasing those as well. But I would be willing to even help divert that water on the north side of that pathway, reshape that land so that it does go down to the road into the waterway.
Speaker O: Down to the road.
Speaker B: I shouldn't tell you all my secrets, but when I was 21 years old— in fact, when I was probably 18 years old, I think— and thought I wanted to be an excavator, this is the guy I learned from. So any excavation I might have known, it probably started there. But if you haven't noticed, he's got equipment and he could probably help us a lot.
Speaker A: So yeah, that's cool.
Speaker B: I was smart enough to get out. He's still in.
Speaker A: Your brother worked for me too. Yeah.
Speaker B: Do you have any questions or do you want to weigh in on your thoughts?
Speaker K: I mean, I'm similar to Councilmember Hewish. I think the wall should— to not sell the property, to have the wall remain. And I like the connection of the pathway. I mean, I know there's a lot of different little pathways scattered throughout that neighborhood. I prefer to see those pathways remain public to be able to go back and forth, but I think the wall looks great.
Speaker O: You did—
Speaker K: it looks like you did a great job, and I'm glad it's been helping your situation there.
Speaker A: Right.
Speaker E: I'd like to offer maybe a different opinion. For me, I think the cleanest solution to this is to consider selling the property to this gentleman, allowing him to continue to own the wall and the property so that we're not taking on a liability of a wall that was built that we have no idea if it's engineered or it's set the way that we want it to be. I'm certainly sympathetic to the issue that you're dealing with and want to find a solution that helps mitigate what you've obviously had to take upon yourself to deal with. So, and for me, that is the— that's the scenario that I would recommend we consider.
Speaker K: So when you say sell the property, so you want—
Speaker E: Yeah, I want him to own the property and the wall.
Speaker K: And the pathway and totally—
Speaker E: Not the pathway, just right to the edge of that.
Speaker H: Okay.
Speaker E: You'll need to sell that little piece.
Speaker K: My primary interest is maintaining the pathway for the city. I'm totally open to this.
Speaker E: I'm not interested in selling the pathway. Everything that you see in orange is what I would consider selling.
Speaker K: Okay, I see what you're saying.
Speaker A: Right. That was the proposal. That makes sense to me.
Speaker B: Do you have— I, I know I saw it one time, but is there a close-up or a picture from, from Mr. Baum's property to the, to the wall? Because I want to— on Brett's point, even though the city would own, you know, the south side, no one could really access it, and it's a pretty steep drop-off. And then, you know, if we kept that, it's going to be weeds, and you basically have to go through his yard to even maintain it. It's, it's kind of blocked off So without moving the wall, from the level of the path, Mark, what's the— to where the ground is on your side, it's a 4 or 5 foot drop-off at least, right?
Speaker A: Yeah.
Speaker B: So you really couldn't access unless you went around the wall, and then to get back up on the path, it's— there's a lot of— you know, I've typically been against selling property, but this one would be pretty hard to even access.
Speaker K: Yeah, I didn't realize— I'm sorry, I misunderstood the initial request. So yeah, if it's just up to that wall portion, I'm fine with parting with that.
Speaker E: It's not that much money.
Speaker A: See, that—
Speaker B: so where the trackhoe's sitting would be city property now.
Speaker G: I agree that it should be city property and that— or no, I agree with Councilmember Wright's comment About selling the land because of the wall built by a private entity instead of building it by the city or a contractor that we chose.
Speaker E: It looks great, by the way.
Speaker G: Yeah, it's not a slam on you.
Speaker E: It's a fence.
Speaker A: I mean, it basically becomes a— it's just a concrete fence, so.
Speaker G: I just think too, just from a liability standpoint, plus it's such a beautiful fence, you should take credit for it and just own it outright.
Speaker A: We have more problems with people jumping up on it and running down it.
Speaker G: Well, this way you could put a sign on it that says private property, no trespassing, because it won't be public land anymore.
Speaker A: We're completely okay with purchasing it if that's available. Okay.
Speaker G: Because it's just a starting— yeah.
Speaker B: Okay, so you okay with that? It's— and this is just to start the process.
Speaker A: This is—
Speaker B: I don't know if you've watched the last few months, but you get to come to a lot of these meetings now because there's public hearings.
Speaker Q: And that's fine.
Speaker F: So I think Council Member Wright brings up an excellent point, and you just mentioned kids running along top of that, the liability risk of them falling, hurting themselves if this city continues to own that That is a risk and a liability financially.
Speaker P: So that's a good point.
Speaker B: Okay, if there's no other questions—
Speaker E: Sounds like I convinced them. I'll make a motion.
Speaker B: Go ahead.
Speaker E: I move that we— that this Eagle Mountain City Council approve a resolution authorizing the land disposal application to proceed and directing staff to begin the notice and public hearing process for a portion of Utah County parcel number 67;236;004, designated as significant real property pursuant to Eagle Mountain Municipal Code 3.30.060. Second.
Speaker K: Second.
Speaker B: Okay, we have a motion by Councilmember Wright and a second by Councilmember Whiting, and we'll start the vote with Councilmember Clark.
Speaker G: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Hewish.
Speaker F: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Whiting.
Speaker M: Yes.
Speaker E: Councilmember Right, right.
Speaker B: Yes, it's reading his name right here. Um, thank you. That passes. So appreciate it. We'll, uh, Lacey will get in touch and let you know what you got to do. Okay, thanks.
Speaker A: Thank you.
Speaker B: All right, item 15A. This is a public hearing, and this is an ordinance of Eagle Mountain City, Utah, amending the official zoning map and future land use map to assign current zoning designations to the Oak Hollow and Parkway Crossroads area And Mickey, you're up.
Speaker H: Do I need the screen? Thank you. Okay, so yes, we are rezoning Oak Hollow and Parkway Crossroads. Um, this is the map for the Oak Hollow area. Um, it's primarily residential, but we did tack on the, uh, commercial community areas along, uh, Pony Express that matches what is to the west there. Um, and then the natural open space for the portion down in the southwest there. This is for the Parkway Crossroads zone. Right now they're all Village Core Commercial, which has been a real headache for the city when considering any applications within those areas. So just getting those updated to Commercial Community there. There is a future land use designation change with this as well. Currently the Oak Hollow area is Residential 1. We We propose changing it to Residential 2, kind of based on all of the lot sizes to keep them consistent. And then the commercial lots are currently Community Commercial. Those will remain Community Commercial. And there's no changes with this. There's no changes in entitlements, traffic generation, anything like that. It's, it's really just the cleanup task of getting into a current zone. And staff recommend that we pass it.
Speaker A: All right.
Speaker B: Is there any questions for staff at this point? This is a public hearing, so if there's no questions for staff, then we can move forward with that. So it is 7:50, and I will open this up for a public— for our public hearing and call that open. And you have no one, not a single person, all these people. All right, is there anyone here that wishes to speak on this item that did not have the chance? All right, with that, we'll—
Speaker E: I'd rather know something more.
Speaker O: I was just gonna say this, this will help us in administering applications. Mickey came to me a while back, if I remember correctly. There was a business license application that came in on, on the corner of Ranches and Pony Express.
Speaker B: And can you hold on one second?
Speaker O: Yeah.
Speaker B: Okay, before you tell us the rest of that from the staff, it's 7:50 and we'll close the public hearing.
Speaker O: Oh, oh, I'm sorry, I jumped the gun there.
Speaker B: I was halfway there.
Speaker D: Yeah.
Speaker F: I was like, you have public comment?
Speaker B: No, no, I do not. All right. So public hearing's closed. And so for context—
Speaker O: Yeah, sorry. We were trying to process an application at that corner, and it was hard because of the old ranch's zoning was making it so we couldn't approve. I can't remember if it was like a— oh, I can't remember what the use was. It was a normal commercial use. that really fit in well in that area, and the current zone just made it pretty tough. So this really helps with those types of applications.
Speaker B: Perfect. Thanks for that context. Is there any other questions or comments?
Speaker G: Actually, Brandon, this is a question, sorry. And I've been trying to, like, quick pull something up, but I know Village Core is very permissive, and it's a historic code and stuff like that. And I know especially up at that crossroads area, lots of different things have been contemplated over the years between a small car dealership to a Beto's, a 7-Eleven, like all of those things. Are there any land uses that we would be taking away by stripping it from village core to community commercial that we're just not picking up on? I just hate That's such a unique spot because it's not completely surrounded by homes, and it's on a busy highway that it could be good commercial right there, and I just wanna make sure we're not cannibalizing it.
Speaker O: No, I think if anything, it opens up for more commercial uses on that corner. Mickey, I'm trying to remember the language of the code. It was, but if it, I think, again, we were having a hard time approving that commercial use because of its strictness. So this was an expansion of the allowance of commercial uses on the property.
Speaker H: Yeah, it was very vaguely worded, I think, was the problem. We have it as a black or white, it's either permitted or it's not. And with that, with the MDA, It wasn't. It was very unclear.
Speaker G: I think too, one of the things that, if I remember correctly, because I've had to look at this piece several times, it feels like in Village Core, mixed use is allowed in that zone.
Speaker B: Right.
Speaker G: And we don't allow that in community commercial. If a landowner came and said, hey, I'd like to do a project similar to the one that's like at Takira 27, and put that there. Is that something that we would just have to consider through a development agreement, or what— how would you approach that?
Speaker O: Yeah, probably through a development agreement.
Speaker G: Okay. All right, thank you.
Speaker B: If there's no other questions, I will entertain a motion.
Speaker K: Mayor, I move the council approve an ordinance of Eagle Mountain City, Utah, amending the official zoning map and future land use map to assign current zone zoning designations to the Oak Hollow and Parkway Crossroads areas.
Speaker E: Second.
Speaker B: Okay, we have a motion by Councilmember Weiding, a second by Councilmember Wright.
Speaker E: Can we stipulate that the zoning will match what's contained in the proposal?
Speaker K: Yes.
Speaker B: Amended motion?
Speaker E: Amended second.
Speaker B: Okay, you good, Lacey? Stephanie? Amend that it just matches the, uh—
Speaker E: We, we amended. I asked, uh, Council Member Whiting, he'd be willing to amend the motion so that the zoning matches what contained within the, the application.
Speaker B: And so motion by Council Member Whiting and second, uh, amended second by Council Member Wright. And we'll start the— you're clear, right? We're good. We'll start the vote with Council Member Hewish?
Speaker L: Yes.
Speaker B: Council Member Whiting?
Speaker K: Yes.
Speaker B: Council Member Wright?
Speaker N: Yes.
Speaker B: And Council Member Clark?
Speaker A: Yes.
Speaker B: All right, thank you. And, uh, next item, 15B, an ordinance of Eagle Mountain City, Utah, enacting Eagle Mountain Municipal Code 1760085 regarding artificial turf. And we have David here with the presentation.
Speaker J: Mayor and council, before you tonight is a Amendment to add regulations for artificial turf. Staff was directed to draw something up for you, present to you. So that's what you see on the screen here. This is actually a code I drafted elsewhere. I tweaked it a bit for our use, but when I did draft this at the previous location, I did consult with artificial turf companies, installers. I didn't know the technical aspects of turf, so I They got their opinions, and that's what was then drafted into the code. And so that's what you see here.
Speaker B: It wasn't Santaquin, was it? Are you bringing all your previous cities? We're tired of hearing—
Speaker J: Hey, if it works, it works, you know. So again, the regulations there, just some information here. You know, right now we're looking at what would be probably a medium pile, 1.5 inches, generally considered to be a good all-around pile depth.
Speaker D: for that.
Speaker J: And when you put turf down, you put in an infill material.
Speaker E: There's—
Speaker J: you can have organic, you can have inorganic. I would recommend staying away from inorganic material. So you'd use things like sand. There's cork. I know there's crushed— I think walnut shells is one as well. Just some—
Speaker N: Whoops.
Speaker J: I had a slide— no, I'm missing a slide. I had another slide here. It's gone for some reason. Anyway, just— it was what infill can do. But so going back again, these are standards that came from turf installers and that then I just transposed into a code.
Speaker B: Are there any questions for staff at this time?
Speaker F: My question was the inorganic organic. You answered it for me.
Speaker J: Yeah, and there's issues, you know, people did, you know, previously when I was going through this process, people did take issue with, you know, it's basically crumb rubber refill or fill. And if you ever watch NFL football or soccer, you see someone tackle, their foot drags along the turf, all this black, that's all crumb rubber.
Speaker F: The Cedar Valley football field is inorganic rubber, yep.
Speaker J: One other then amendment, The other thing would be this— in the process of doing this, I came across this section too. State code does not allow us to regulate rear yard landscaping, and so we'd remove that. And of course, we have nothing to do with CC&Rs. We don't enforce those, and so that would come out as well.
Speaker F: So question on zones, neighborhoods. would be available to any residential—
Speaker J: Yeah, the front yard, they'd still have to meet 50% live material landscaping. Tree canopies don't count, but shrubs, you could still grow other bushes, shrubs, whatever. They can come up with whatever combination. But they still have to have a minimum of 50% live plant coverage. So this typically may be more accent-type use for the turf. Somebody wouldn't just come blanket artificial turf their front yard and that's it. And that's again, then the code's written that that's not considered landscaping.
Speaker F: So embarrassing story. When I moved into my house, we had BlueStakes come out. They didn't mark where the nat gas line was, and I laid the trencher right on top of the nat gas line in my front yard. And I just thought, man, if I would have just had artificial turf It would have been so easy. No sprinkler lines, just lay it down, forget about it. Are there any issues with people having artificial turf if we need to access nat gas lines, water lines, electrical?
Speaker J: Yeah, obviously.
Speaker F: Like they just take the risk that we're going to have to pull it up?
Speaker J: Yeah, obviously the first 10 feet behind Tivoli sidewalk is a public utility easement. It would be up to the property owners and working with whatever—
Speaker B: if they do need to get in to work back and forth on how they would I think most of those easements, like when the internet companies come through and stuff, they have to restore it. So if a landowner, if they tore the property up, they'd have to restore it to what it was.
Speaker J: And you're here to say that your gas line was disrupted. That's good you're still here.
Speaker F: We had to evacuate the neighborhood, parts of it, for a But, but it got resolved.
Speaker J: Uh, the Planning Commission did look at this. They just wanted to make a small change, which I put on here onto, uh, letter E. They just wanted to word it a little bit differently on the 2.5-foot distance from tree trunks. Um, so I, I modified that, that language just a bit.
Speaker B: No other questions? All right, then this is a public hearing. So with that explanation, we'll go to that point. It is 8:00, and we will open the public hearing. Not a soul. All right, is there anyone here that would like to speak on this item that did not have an opportunity? Seeing no one, we'll close the public hearing at 8:00 and come back to the council with any other questions or motion.
Speaker F: Mayor, I'll make a motion, uh, for the council to approve an ordinance of Eagle Mountain, uh, 15B, an ordinance of Eagle Mountain, Utah, enacting Eagle Mountain, Eagle Mountain Municipal Code Section 17.60.085 regarding artificial turf and amending Section 17.60.100 residential landscape requirements. Second.
Speaker B: Okay, we have a motion by Council Member Hewish and a second by Council Member Whiting. we get on the motion. And with that, we'll start the vote with Councilmember Whiting.
Speaker K: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Wright.
Speaker E: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Clark.
Speaker G: Yes.
Speaker B: And Councilmember Huish.
Speaker F: Yes.
Speaker E: Putting green, here I come.
Speaker B: Okay, thank you. All right, thanks. Is there any other legislative— okay, we will invite John Magnus up for item 16A, just legislative Priorities, uh, for an update.
Speaker E: Good evening, Mayor, Council. Question for you. There was a, um, on the list we were going to have specially designed, um, fence panels for arterial roads. It was cost prohibitive, so we didn't go that way, but there was a discussion about probably making or possibly making a design standard. Is still that the council Do you want a standardized wall through the whole city for—
Speaker B: I think— is it possible you can ask us at the next meeting? I know that was me and Councilmember Wood, and I think to really scratch that without at least his input— Sure, no problem. Is that fair? Does everybody here just want to—
Speaker A: That's fair.
Speaker B: All right. So bring that back.
Speaker M: Okay, that's fine.
Speaker E: It's on my list. I just wanna make sure that I haven't dropped the ball, 'cause I remember there was a discussion, we just never figured out what it was. Do you have anything for me?
Speaker B: Anything else that you wanna have John work on?
Speaker D: Okay.
Speaker M: Thank you.
Speaker B: Thanks. 17, this is the council items and liaison reports. We'll start over here with Council Member Clark.
Speaker G: Thank you, Mayor. Um, my liaison assignments are really with, um, the American Legion and, um, with Planning Commission. And we covered a couple Planning Commission things today. Uh, the American Legion and Community Services Board— um, the American Legion and our event staff, like I mentioned earlier in my comments, are going to be kind of teaming up to make sure that the Veterans Breakfast happens. And as our tradition is—
Speaker B: That's this Saturday, right?
Speaker G: Nope, the 14th, not the Saturday following. There's a very important, uh, holy war of football that will be happening on Saturday morning. So, um, as is our tradition, council, um, and mayor are invited to come and participate in helping serve and just greet the veterans and their families and just be a part of that morning.
Speaker N: I—
Speaker G: it was— was it 8:30? It's on Ben's thing, the veterans breakfast. I think it was 8:00 to 10:30.
Speaker C: 8:00 to 10:30.
Speaker G: And it's at the Ivory Barn. So— and they always need help to set up and they always need help to take down. And the American Legion is currently working on the program. Um, you may be tapped for something in that, but I just would encourage council to come. It's a special Saturday for us to show up and support our veterans. So thanks, guys.
Speaker E: Thanks, Mayor. Um, I'll report on my 3 assignments. DRC, uh, I hope each of you get a chance to sit on DRC and just see how good our team is as they interact. They've made some changes. They've been instituted some changes that I think are beneficial in creating efficiencies. In bringing everyone into the meeting and scheduling regular meetings with some of our, some of our applicants that are doing large projects and multiple, multiple applications at the same time, just to, just to kind of keep the wheels moving and make sure that issues are being addressed and that we're being responsive to those applications. So I'm grateful for that. Seniors, we talked about the chili cook-off. We gave you a report on that. Just if you know a family that is struggling, that's a senior family, and they're— they might have a need for a turkey dinner to be delivered, go on our website and fill that information out. They're taking applications, the seniors are right now, for 20 families that they're going to provide a Thanksgiving meal to. And when I say a meal, all of the goods and fixin's so that they cook their own meal and take care of their family. So if you have someone you'd like to nominate for that, the application is open on our city's website. And then lastly, just the ULTC. You talked a little bit about it, Councilmember Clark. The legislative session is going to be up and coming and they're going to start LPCs here right away. And, and, and our fall conference was— I don't— I wouldn't call it a Retreat, I would call it. I don't know. Yeah, worse than that for me. It's almost like you get sent to timeout, adult timeout. But the networking and what you learn there I think is really tremendously valuable.
Speaker K: Youth Council, we had a really, really fun Halloween party at my house. And kudos to the advisors who run that. The advisors were, you know, we were texting sort of with myself and the advisors whether we should cancel because there was a lot of rain that night and we, and we had planned it primarily outside. And instead of making the decision themselves, they said, well, let's let the Youth Council make the decision. The Youth Council said, no, let's still do it. And tons of kids ended up showing up. It was awesome. I'm so glad they kept going, kept that. So So we had a lot of fun with that. Chamber has tons of stuff going on. They're doing an awesome job. And then my other one is the library, and there's nothing really to report from that. I do have actually a real quick question on the consent agenda. So one item on the consent agenda, there were 2 recommendations from the Planning Commission relative to the UCCU site. So when we approved that consent agenda, did it also approve those recommendations from the Planning Commission, or do we need to recall that item and specifically include their recommendations?
Speaker M: So what you approved was the site plan, however it was— however it is in the consent agenda. So if those recommendations are incorporated, then yes. If they're not, then no.
Speaker F: Were they?
Speaker K: Do you know if they were? I wonder if we should— is that— are we allowed to recall? Specific about that? Yeah, and I apologize, I just caught it now. It was in my notes, but it was in out of order. And so when I was looking through my own personal notes for the meeting today, I put that unfortunately in the wrong spot.
Speaker B: Yes, Mickey, do you know? That was Mickey's item.
Speaker O: Mickey? I know that there was an issue with the tier level of trees, and I believe we had to go back and correct those. So Mickey, I don't know if you can come up and explain She knows more about that issue than I do.
Speaker B: If it was included, we're good. If it's not, the intent is to include it.
Speaker H: It was resolved before we sent you any, before it came to you guys. All of the paperwork that you have show what was approved.
Speaker B: So those 2 items were—
Speaker K: And it should have— Oh, sorry, go ahead.
Speaker B: The 2 were already addressed and it was included.
Speaker H: From Planning Commission.
Speaker E: Yes.
Speaker B: And it's included in the motion.
Speaker H: Did we approve the motion with the— I don't know how it works. I'm sorry.
Speaker M: So the question is, did you incorporate the Planning Commission recommendations into the site plan that was presented to the council for approval or not?
Speaker H: Yes.
Speaker M: Then yes, they were approved.
Speaker B: So, and if for some reason the paperwork's not correct, that is our intent. So, yes.
Speaker J: Okay.
Speaker H: They specifically gave their recommendation with the 8.5-foot variance.
Speaker K: And then there was something with the trees too.
Speaker H: Yeah, and the condition with the trees, which I don't believe we can condition the approval on because they had already met it anyway.
Speaker E: Okay.
Speaker M: Yeah, I don't— yeah, I know that that was something that a certain Planning Commissioner wanted. Now, this is definitely— I'm definitely remembering this from Planning Commission. But again, it's not— I don't think it's something that our code says says you can require— our code dictates what type of trees can go in or are required where, so we can't change that.
Speaker H: And gives the final approval to the arborist who signed off on it as well, on both plans.
Speaker G: With that, it, it may be good, Mayor, to, um, take a look at that because I think there is some discrepancy between what the tree guy says.
Speaker E: Let's do this. Let's make a motion to reconsider the consent agenda.
Speaker M: I, I will say that both of these recommendations are not things that we can legally compel.
Speaker E: They're not what?
Speaker M: They're not— their recommendations are not items, things that we can legally compel UCCU to do.
Speaker E: So it's immaterial is what I'm hearing you say.
Speaker H: Yes.
Speaker E: Okay, then nobody second the motion. I just mean forget it.
Speaker R: Back to what I was saying.
Speaker E: In fact, I'm going to rescind it.
Speaker G: Back to what I was saying. I think that there were some legitimate concerns by people who work in this industry who also serve on Planning Commission, and it may be worth asking for some work to be done on the clarification of what the tree guide says versus what code says, because that's where the issue came up.
Speaker E: Tree gate.
Speaker G: Tree, yeah, tree gate is what we'll call it. But the guide spells out something, and then code basically defers to the arborist, and there was a discrepancy in that planning commissioner's mind of which trumped what or which was the hierarchy in the decision-making process. So maybe at some point we should have some clarity in that. That's all I'm suggesting.
Speaker K: So I was looking back at the 2 recommendations. So the other recommendation was to include signage to direct larger vehicles to the wider outside lane, and you're saying we can't?
Speaker M: Our code doesn't require that.
Speaker C: Okay.
Speaker M: So we can't mandate it. I think they seem willing to do that.
Speaker H: Yeah, they did do it.
Speaker I: Yeah.
Speaker G: Yeah, the applicant, said that they would do that.
Speaker O: So we'll work on, on, uh, clarifying that.
Speaker G: Awesome. Yep.
Speaker C: Thanks.
Speaker B: No other, uh, liaison.
Speaker F: And then, uh, just a couple, couple things. The Community Services Board rescheduled their next public meeting is on November 18th, I believe, from 4 to 6 o'clock.
Speaker O: Steve can probably confirm.
Speaker J: 4?
Speaker E: That early?
Speaker I: Or 7?
Speaker E: 4 o'clock.
Speaker B: It is at 4?
Speaker F: It's at 4 o'clock.
Speaker L: Yep.
Speaker F: It's a little, little early in the day, but that, that's when the next Community Services Board meeting is. And I know they're planning on talking about some of these land disposition items that we've forwarded to them. And then an unofficial assignment that I've given to myself is we have a city podcast that records this meeting as well as the Planning Commission meeting. And I'll tell you, if you're stuck in traffic on your way out of the city, there's nothing better than to listen to a Planning Commission meeting. It is super helpful.
Speaker B: You want people falling asleep and reading?
Speaker E: We don't want people going to sleep, Councilmember Huebsch. We want them to stay alert.
Speaker F: But in our— one of the things that we learned through this year, going through the tax increase and all of that, is transparency. And, you know, I found going back through watching these videos on the city website, you'd have to do a lot of start and stop and go back. And what timestamp was I on? With a podcast, it's very easy.
Speaker C: You can—
Speaker F: you may not know everybody's voices, but you can hear at least the conversations that's happening. So I would just encourage for people to listen to the podcast to be informed about what's happening in your city. And secondly, I'd also encourage the mayor or others within the city to maybe go on the podcast and record, uh, some time to learn about how are streets built and what are easements within our city and all the different things that we have going on. How do, how do sewers work and water systems? I think that would be really interesting content to add to the podcast. So I just invite those of our staff that have the capacity to do that to, to do so.
Speaker N: Thanks, Mayor.
Speaker B: All right, thanks. The— I mean, I just want to bring up one other thing unless somebody has I've kind of updated you on all the stuff that I work on. It's a good list. But speaking of our boards and liaison assignments, typically around January we'll switch those out. But just so people are aware, so those committees are aware, I kind of want to start working on that. I looked at it earlier this week. So if there are specific assignments you can't do or ones that you're interested in as we kind of shuffle this, The way I've always seen this is it's a discussion with the body. It's not an assignment necessarily for me. So I want to get some input as we go through the week. And, you know, some of those boards, like I think the seniors meet at 10 o'clock.
Speaker E: They meet at 10 o'clock on a Tuesday, Council Tuesday.
Speaker B: So I've got the opportunity to do that a lot. I know you have. I know Councilmember Burnham used to sit on that a lot. And so it's an availability thing.
Speaker E: But DRC is only like Yeah, it's a short meeting, right?
Speaker B: So any of those that you have time for where others might have other obligations, you know, I'm telling— and you guys went to the chili cook-off. It's, it's a good group to be with, those guys. The other Youth Council, there's some good stuff. So I just want some feedback, and if we can start talking so that we can have those changes made.
Speaker G: Do you want to see the feedback now, or—
Speaker B: I think we need to Have some discussions. So, okay, I know we got time, but—
Speaker E: Can you just send the list out, Mayor, and let us review it? Yeah, I know you have— have Lacey do that maybe for us.
Speaker B: You have the updated list, and can you email this to council?
Speaker E: That would be great, because then, then we can kind of become familiar with the assignments that we're not carrying.
Speaker B: Perfect, thank you.
Speaker E: LPC's Mondays. I mean, especially during the legislative session, every Monday for a couple hours, right?
Speaker B: Monday at noon, right?
Speaker E: Yeah, 12.
Speaker F: That's an important—
Speaker B: Yeah, and that's been the 3 of us, and Ben's been on that. So if somebody wants to jump in there.
Speaker E: So it's fun. I mean, but we don't do anything during the week. But what I really should say is I don't really work anymore. I just work in my city council job. That's— last week I spent— I, I was at my office on Monday until noon, and the rest of the week I was gone out with city stuff.
Speaker B: It's busy, busy, busy. Well, If there's no other items, then I'll open— we do have some more closed session items, so I would request that we take about a 5-minute break. We'll get set up and then we'll go do that.
Speaker E: I move to adjourn to a closed session. Let's see, for the purpose of discussion pending or reasonably imminent litigation, the character, professional competence, or physical or mental health of an individual, the purchase, lease, sell, or exchange of real property, a proposed development agreement, project proposal, or financing proposal related to the development of land owned by the state or political subdivision, and/or the deployment of security personnel, devices, or systems pursuant to Section 52-4-205, Section 1 of the Utah Code Annotated.
Speaker G: Second.
Speaker B: Okay, we have a motion by Councilmember Wright and a second by Councilmember Clark. And we'll start the voting with Councilmember Wright.
Speaker E: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Clark.
Speaker G: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Hewish.
Speaker F: Yes.
Speaker B: Councilmember Whiting.
Speaker K: Yes.
Speaker B: Okay, at 8:16 we'll go to closed session, and when we're done we'll come back here for adjournment. All right, it is 10:27 and we are back in our council meeting, and I'm entertaining a motion.
Speaker E: Motion to adjourn.
Speaker F: Second.
Speaker B: A motion by Council Member Wright and a second by Council Member Hewish. All in favor?
Speaker R: Aye.
Speaker B: Any opposed? Seeing none, we are adjourned at 10:27.
Speaker C: Thank you.